The Five Pillars of Belonging: Why They’re Significant

BY Michael Stahl | May 11, 2023


Right now, David Bator is the managing director of the Achievers Workforce Institute, the information wing for the employee-experience platform Achievers. But at a previous time in his life, he worked for a different company, and had a boss that did not make him feel as though he belonged in the organization—at all. 

Bator was injured in a bike-riding accident on his way to work one day, and though in the moments after his fall, in which he suffered a broken leg and a gash above his eye that required many stitches, his first thought was, “Let me fix the chain on my bike and get to work.” Seeing Bator’s condition, a construction worker stopped him from doing so and, eventually, Bator served a two-day stay in the hospital.

Still, he worked remotely from his home as soon as he could, but his manager was so worried about a productivity drop that he ordered Bator to return to the office. Bator walked the office on crutches and paid for car services out of his own pocket for a month so he could commute to and from his job. 

At one point his boss stopped him in the hall and asked how he was doing. Bator opened up about his struggles managing the commute, his pain and his family, which included a couple kids, while recovering from his injuries. 

Then came the a-ha moment for Bator. His boss said, “No, how’s your work going? I only care about what goes on here.”

“Needless to say, I no longer work at that place,” Bator told a room full of guests, who issued a round of applause. He recounted the story at From Day One’s conference in Salt Lake City, where he led a workshop titled, “The Significance of the Five Pillars of Belonging,” the title of which was initially part of an Achievers Workforce Institute report.

“The definition that we came to out of that body of research was that belonging is an experience of connection, security and community,” said Bator. “And it’s really a feeling of being at home, without reservation, regardless of who you are, the job you do or where you do that job.”

In order to foster a sense of belonging across a workforce, per Achievers’ five pillars, leaders must ensure that they feel “welcomed,” “known,” “included,” “supported” and “connected.
 “These five pillars have a particularly elastic quality, to build employee experiences that engage our people,” Bator said. “Again, regardless of who they are, the job they do, how long they’ve been doing it, their level of seniority or, fundamentally over the last number of years, where they physically do that job.”

Welcomed

Starting with the first of the five pillars, Bator suggested leaders distribute tangible greeting cards signed by team members that welcome new hires to the company. He urged managers of new hires to make sure they provide recognition to a new team member within their first week of work in their new organization. 

“Do they have the opportunity through things like onboarding surveys, to reflect on the support and the resources that they received during their first 30, 60, 90 days?” Bator said. “These are all great instruments that you can use to drive that feeling of someone feeling welcomed when they join a team or, indeed, your organization.”

He added that efforts to help a worker feel “welcome” in the office should be extended to every worker, not just new ones, across their respective stays with the company—which, with this and other steps taken by managers, will hopefully be long and productive ones.   

“That feeling of being welcomed is about every space we share with anyone,” Bator said. “It’s about every transaction that we have at work. It’s about every room we walk into every experience. And so the challenge for all of us in creating conditions for hopefully award-winning employee experience, is thinking about what are the things we can do every single day. How do you make every day feel like a ‘day one’ for your people?”

According to research from the Achievers Workshop Institute, Bator said if employees are made to feel “welcome,” they are twice as likely to feel like they “belong,” too. If a given organization’s workers are anything like Bator was when he had his unfortunate bike accident, making them feel unwelcome will lead to all the pitfalls that come with poor retention rates.

Known

In making employees feel “known,” at a baseline level, all it takes is a little bit of listening. Give workers a space to express themselves freely and when they do open up, take stock in their values and their needs and try to align with them and supply solutions when possible. This will enhance a worker’s sense of connection with their employer.

“Our obligation is to create conditions so that an individual can bring their whole self to work,” said Bator. “And on a tactical, practical level, this can look like a bunch of different things.”

Giving more specifics he said making workers feel “known” could be the byproduct of recognizing them for accomplishments and milestones, both personal and professional. Even something as simple as making sure managers know how to pronounce a worker’s surname could have an outsized impact because it shows care and attention to detail. 

“It means giving your employees the opportunity to use pronouns that express their true identity,” said Bator. “And you can only do [all this] if you begin to ask, and if you begin to create safe spaces for people to share who they are. When you do this, you build trust.”

Included

Helping an employee feel “included,” Bator continued, may have the most significant impact in terms of nurturing a worker’s sense of belonging and better ensuring their engagement and retention. 

“It’s, ‘Do I have a shot here, to begin with?’” said Bator. “The narrow view, ironically, is when we think about inclusion through the lens of diversity, equity, and inclusion, and the things that we can do to create table stakes for every single employee. I think the broader view, however, is about creating opportunities for our people to share in co-creating what their employee experience actually looks like.”

He suggests building a safe space that gives employees a comfort level to not only make their opinions heard and acknowledged, but to also come up with “a great idea” and have it “heard by the right person in an organization.”

Data from recent Achievers Workshop Institute research said organizations that for feedback from their employees at least four times a year have 50% higher levels of engagement, Bator said, while 88% of those employees are more likely to feel valued.

Supported

To make workers feel “supported,” Achievers research says, give them a sense of empowerment tied to their potential long-term success by supplying them with necessary tools, training and resources. Provide them opportunities for professional growth and to have a healthy work-life balance as well.

“When I think about what this pillar really means, I think immediately of managers,” Bator said. “Whether you pick social justice, the pandemic, new modes of working, take your pick, your managers are on the frontlines with their people every single day. And what we see is that when an individual has a strong relationship with their manager, they feel individually resilient.”

Thus, they are more capable of overcoming challenges, a belief that aforementioned Achievers research shows many workers don’t have.

Connected

And calling back to the fifth and final pillar of employee belonging, Bator said, “At a basic level, what being ‘connected’ is about is: Do your employees have the opportunity to build a diverse network, inside their work circle and outside of their work circle?’”

He revealed that more Achievers Workshop Institute research shows that when organizations have connection tools, they are great at driving not only connection, but trust and support, as well as other worthwhile sensations. 

“But what I would argue to you is that connection is much more of a philosophy than it is a cool feature that you can share with your employees,”Bator said. “Fundamentally, it’s about: Is it easy for your [managers] to access the people and the skills that they need every single day so that they can be productive and positive from anywhere.”

It’ll be much less of a challenge for employees to sever those connections, with their managers, fellow workers and their general work responsibilities, if they don’t feel a strong sense of belonging. 

Bator knows this first hand. He has the scars to prove it.

Editor’s note: From Day One thanks its partner, Achievers, for sponsoring this workshop.

Michael Stahl is a New York City-based freelance journalist, writer, and editor. You can read more of his work at MichaelStahlWrites.com, follow him on Twitter @MichaelRStahl, and order his first book, the autobiography of Major League Baseball pitcher Bartolo Colón, at Abrams Books. 

(Featured image: David Bator conducting the workshop in Salt Lake City.)


RELATED STORIES

Full-Cycle Recruiting: How to Hire Top Talent With a Holistic Approach

The U.S. labor market has trailed expectations this year. The number of open jobs has been sinking since the beginning of 2024, and it’s getting harder to find a job, applicants say. Job seekers are frustrated not only because there are fewer open roles, but because hiring processes are so poor. LinkedIn is full of users writing about their terrible job-seeking experiences with confusing or unusually protracted hiring processes, fake job postings, and ghosting recruiters.Kim Stevens is the manager of talent acquisition at Lever, an applicant tracking system. She’s spent a decade in talent acquisition, working across industries, and at both B2B and B2C companies. She says it doesn’t have to be this way, and employers have an obligation to do better–by their recruiters and their applicants.“Full-cycle recruiting is a holistic approach,” Stevens said during a From Day One webinar on how full-cycle recruiting can help employers hire top talent. “Instead of passing candidates from one recruiter to the next to move them through the process, there is a single recruiter managing the process from the initial job requisition all the way to how new hires are integrated into the company.”Many companies have already adopted a full-cycle process, but some are still stuck on old models, like a sourcing-led path where one recruiter brings in the talent then candidates are passed among the team; very early on, the hiring experience is interrupted. For job candidates, full-cycle recruiting should be unnoticeable. “Having one person manage all of it does create a more seamless transition for the candidate and one point of contact. If it’s done well, it’s very good as far as the candidate experience goes.”Kim Stevens of Lever by Employ led the webinar (photo courtesy of Stevens)A full-cycle approach is important now because the labor market is so tight, she said. “We have so many [job seekers] in the market, and we can empathize with that and embed that in our thought process when we’re creating processes within our [applicant tracking system] to not only manage the volume, but to focus on all of the different parts of the process. We should ask ‘How can they work for us, and how can they work for the candidate?’ And you really have to do that with automation.”Stevens spent a year on the job market as a candidate herself and saw how brutal the process can be for job seekers. “It made me think about all the times where I could have done my job better; I owed it to candidates to give them a better experience. I needed to reset and really value what my job is and the impact that it can make on people, their lives, and their livelihood.”She also felt the importance of having a single point of contact at the hiring company. “I saw the good and the bad and the ugly when it came to the candidate experience.” Whether it was being passed around among a recruiting team or having to create a username and password for every application (even if it was at the same company).“Being in the job market is stressful enough. If we can mitigate some of those steps and automate and customize, it’s such an important way to create that seamless experience for the company and for the candidate. There are so many different layers within your ATS that you can customize, like candidate communications, ensuring that they’re not only getting followed up with after they apply but that they’re getting updates about where we are in the process.”Full-cycle recruiting teams, juggling multiple activities and multiple candidates at once, have to be really good at time management. New adopters may require training before they’re ready to fly solo. A good applicant tracking system, and maybe even a little artificial intelligence, can help with multitasking, but “technology should be viewed as an enhancement, not a replacement for that human interaction,” Stevens said.For instance, full-cycle can be enhanced by some smart, time-saving changes. “It was ingrained into me by a previous leader of mine, that if you’re having to do something more than once and it’s the same task: Automate it,” she said. “If you’re getting the same questions about–let’s say, benefits–then create something that’s automated, where you can just reply with a signature.”The recruiting process is often the first impression a company will make on job seekers. And if it’s a bad one, the relationship can sour–or solidify–as soon as it begins. A good ATS doesn’t solve all problems. Other factors, like a company’s employer brand will make it easier–or harder–to recruit the workforce you need. Stevens recalled working in university recruiting for a past employer whose employer brand was so strong that when she walked onto the University of Texas at Austin campus, she felt like a celebrity. Students wanted to see what the company would do next, they wanted to talk to recruiters. Of course, recruiting is a huge part of that reputation.Every step of the process is an opportunity for thoughtful interaction with job candidates. It’s a reflection of your company and what the employee experience is like. “There’s so much to say about a full-cycle recruiting process, but also an ATS that enables that process and makes it more streamlined, especially given how many candidates in the market are already stressed. It’s so important as leaders and as companies to keep that in mind. The reality of our market is that we have so many people in it–how can we really make sure that our ATS is working for them too?”Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, Lever by Employ, for sponsoring this webinar.Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza is a freelance journalist and From Day One contributing editor who writes about work, the job market, and women’s experiences in the workplace. Her work has appeared in the Economist, the BBC, The Washington Post, Quartz, Fast Company, and Digiday’s Worklife.

Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza | October 04, 2024

Beyond Birth: How Employers Can Invest in the Postpartum Period

More and more organizations are realizing that providing fertility benefits is essential to support and retain employees who are looking to start their family-building journey. However, a key period may be getting overlooked in the process: postpartum. How are organizations supporting employees after they give birth and return to work?During a From Day One webinar, experts from Ovia Health discussed the pregnancy and postpartum risk factors that can influence long-term health outcomes, as well as the ways employers can invest in meaningful end-to-end digital health solutions that support employees throughout their entire care continuum.Health in the ‘Fourth Trimester’Moderator Sarah Begley, director of member content at Atria, says that the postpartum period is often referred to as “the fourth trimester.” This time can require just as much special care and attention as the months of pregnancy. “The government has expanded [the postpartum period] to 12 months,” said Corrinne Hobbs, general manager and VP, employer market organization at Ovia Health. This is a significant and relatively recent change in thinking.“When we originally thought about postpartum, it was geared toward the six weeks after birth, whether that was vaginal delivery or C-section,” said Leslie Saltzman, chief medical officer at Ovia Health. “At the end of that period, the mother would go back to their OBGYN or their nurse midwife, be cleared and told ‘everything’s fine. You can go back to your normal life.’” In reality, Saltzman says, the first six weeks, when everyone is giving the mother time and attention, is the easy part. It’s what comes next that can be the challenge. “The exhaustion in those periods after can be worse,” she said, as can the complications that appear later after the stress-test of childbirth.“In the U.S., many of us have heard about the high rates of maternal death that we have compared to our peer nations. 65% of those deaths actually happen in the postpartum period,” Saltzman said, noting that fatal complications can arise when mothers are back home and more or less alone. She notes infections, high blood pressure, cardiovascular complications like cardiomyopathy or blood clots, and mental health issues like postpartum depression or psychosis are conditions that need to be monitored and addressed during this period. And complications diagnosed during pregnancy such as preeclampsia or gestational diabetes can increase the risk of cardiovascular disease in women for the rest of their lives.What Postpartum Care Looks LikeThe American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology recommends that every person that has a delivery has contact with their provider, whether that's OBGYN or a midwife, within three weeks, with ongoing care as needed up until a final visit at around 12 weeks. “What that’s translating to for most people is a phone call followed by a single visit,” Saltzman said. Only about 60% of people even go to that postpartum visit, Saltzman says. Many people don’t even have 12 weeks off for parental leave, making it even more challenging to attend the appointment. Most daycare centers won’t even accept children until they are at least six weeks old. “You’re still trying to figure out how to feed your baby at that point,” Begley noted. And because we’re living less and less in multigenerational homes, Salztman says, essential knowledge in baby care is not being passed down.Leaders from Ovia Health spoke with Sarah Begley during the From Day One webinar (photo by From Day One)Among those that do attend the checkup: “After you have that visit with your OBGYN and you get clear that your cervix is normal, your incision looks okay, and talk about ongoing needs for birth control… New mothers are then left in the system where it is their responsibility to identify if they have a complication and try to figure out whether that needs care or not. And then have to make the appointments and go,” Saltzman said. “This is where the existing system doesn’t really meet the needs.”How Digital Solutions Can Bridge the GapDigital healthcare programs through an employer can provide structured and personalized access to information on health and baby care at this crucial time in a parent’s life that gives them, Hobbs says. A digital solution can help a person record their symptoms and then provide insight into what might be happening and whether to seek care, potentially saving them the time and expense of a doctor’s visit, Saltzman says.These digital solutions, Hobbs says, should include information on physical recovery and support, postpartum depression screenings, lactation coaching, sleep training, and appointment management for the parent and the baby, including vaccination schedules. “A tool that can help you manage all of that while you're going through this physical, emotional, and mental transition would be tremendously helpful,” Hobbs said.Ovia Health’s Postpartum SolutionIn addition to the digital solutions mentioned above, Hobbs says Ovia Health’s platform also provides information on potential pregnancy complications and associated risk factors, such as atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, which is “one of the most expensive health conditions.” The platform incorporates all potential aspects of life tied to pregnancy. “Our solution addresses reproductive life, planning and contraception, pelvic floor recovery, return to work, social and financial planning, social determinants to health and equity, and navigation of care,” Hobbs said.“Our solution starts with recovery, so we are meeting people where they are in their individualized journey,” Hobbs said. Symptom trackers encourage people to engage with the platform’s dashboard daily to provide checklists and guidance along every step of the way. Behind the tracking are clinical algorithms primed to notice an impending issue. Critical alerts let the person know right away if something is abnormal, with care team members, who are licensed clinical staff, ready to respond and guide the parent through next steps.The platform also encourages a segue back from OBGYN care to primary care and routine screenings since. Mothers often neglect their own basic non-pregnancy related healthcare once children arrive, Saltzman says.Building an Inclusive Postpartum PolicyEmployers, Begley says, should be “shifting their workplace culture to be more inclusive of those returning from maternity leave, parental leave, or being a new parent.” This includes several key factors, as described below.Paid parental leave is crucial to postpartum recovery. “It really helps women to overcome or traverse the physical, emotional, and mental needs of being a parent,” Hobbs said. “Living in the United States, there's not a standard or universal paid parental leave requirement. So, employers are left to decide whether they can and will offer that.” This means women especially are often required to return to work during those first 12 months when they are still physically and mentally recovering. It’s worth noting, Hobbs says, “that women who take paid parental leave have lower rates of postpartum depression. And women of color are more likely to have jobs where paid leave is not offered at all.” Employers looking to cultivate a diverse workforce would do well to invest in paid parental leave whenever possible, for as long as possible.Flexibility and inclusivity in spaces also matters. Physical space for pumping and breastfeeding also builds a welcoming and safe environment for employees who are in-person. Flexible scheduling to allow for childcare, healthcare appointments, and other issues is another way employers can support new parents–without cutting into their sick time.Management training is important to make sure leaders understand parental policies and how to interact with workers in an inclusive manner, regardless of their family situation, can ease the process for the whole team. In turn, employees also need to be trained on how to communicate their needs.Lastly, transition plans should be put in place to allow employees on leave to be able to ensure their continued professional development and assignments. “We're often afraid to step away because we feel like it might set us back. Adjusting the culture to support the employee and having that manager training to create that inclusive environment related to situations like this are critically important,” Hobbs said. “It really improves the workforce culture around [pregnancy] and postpartum.”Editor's note: From Day One thanks our partner, Ovia Health, for sponsoring this webinar. Katie Chambers is a freelance writer and award-winning communications executive with a lifelong commitment to supporting artists and advocating for inclusion. Her work has been seen in HuffPost and several printed essay collections, among others, and she has appeared on Cheddar News, iWomanTV, On New Jersey, and CBS New York.

Katie Chambers | October 01, 2024

How HR Can Become a Strategic Partner in Annual Business Planning

Poor planning returns poor results. In a company where the workforce is unprepared to meet shifting business needs, organizational performance can drop by as much as 26 percentage points, Gartner found in 2024. Human resources is responsible for delivering a workforce fit to meet the firm’s goals–no matter how fickle–so when business leaders plan poorly, or plan alone, HR teams struggle.John Bernatovicz is the founder of human capital management platform Willory and the author of HR Like a Boss: Your Guide to Amazingly Awesome HR. He believes the buck doesn’t stop with HR or talent acquisition; the business plan is a shared responsibility. “If you don’t feel like your company is effective in annual planning, look no further than your CEO, your board, or other key executives responsible for driving that critical business function,” he said during a From Day One webinar on how to become a strategic HR partner in your global annual business planning. Most executives have a vision for the future of the company, but many fail to consider how their workforce will get them there.Just 32% of talent acquisition leaders feel like strategic partners to their organization, according to 2024 research from the Josh Bersin Co. Business leaders that consider workforce planning immaterial are an acute frustration for TA.Human capital has always been a vital business asset, so why is now the time for HR to insist on having a place in annual planning? According to Sofia Moll, head of global talent management at HiBob, the effects of the pandemic continue to linger over working models, still influencing where and how talent is found. Employee expectations have also shifted, not just regarding compensation and benefits, but also career trajectories and skill development. Further, artificial intelligence is already coloring the skills employees are developing–and setting new standards for productivity.Becoming a Strategic Partner in Annual PlanningEarning a place in annual planning requires human resources people to think like business people, panelists agreed. HR may not think in numbers or spreadsheets, but executives certainly do, Bernatovicz says. Unless talent acquisition learns to link workers to revenue and teach executives to do the same, they won’t prove their relevance. “I see oftentimes that companies look at the bottom of the P&L first, not realizing that profit is an outcome of a number of unique things that are going to happen and run effectively in a strategic manner.”The panelists spoke about "Becoming an HR Strategic Partner in Your Global Business Annual Planning" during the From Day One webinar (photo by From Day One)“They need that data to understand where you’re coming from,” said Lane McFarland, senior director of talent management at data intelligence company Flashpoint. “Maybe the finance team just needs to hear the cost savings initiatives or the vacancy savings during the hiring period. Maybe the CEO just needs to know how many [positions] you’ve fulfilled by department.”Strategic thinkers ask good questions and answer them. Know the short-term and long-term business goals–and whether you have the workforce to achieve them, McFarland said. Inventory the skills of your team and find the gaps. If you don’t have what you need, can you develop those skills, or should you hire from the outside? Consider potential labor market shifts and how they might bump up against those plans. Could overall market swings change the business needs in the coming year? What are the consequences of hiring now versus later? What are the risks of over-hiring? What happens when you overload a manager and it pushes them out the door? If you hire in less expensive markets to save money, can you properly support those employees? What about regulatory requirements? Business leaders rely on their HR partners to inform them on the labor market and advise on how it will help or hinder achieving business goals.It’s not enough to be only a dollars-and-cents business contributor: Trust and influence are ultimately won through relationships. Start with the business leaders you already know, said Moll. That might be the sales director or head of content marketing. “Just get on their calendar for 15 minutes or 20 minutes every other week or every month to talk about what they care about,” she said. “Start learning about their business: What are the metrics that they are looking at? What are the pain points they’re experiencing?”Bernatovicz recommended starting with the finance team in particular. “Develop a relationship with [the finance practitioner] at whatever level you’re at, so if you’re the head of HR, then that’s the CFO. If you’re a manager, then find a manager. Get to know them as individuals, what makes them tick, why they’re working at the company, what they do outside of work.”As you embed yourself with your business counterparts, track the impact of decisions made about the workforce and provide regular updates, Moll advised. Know your time to hire and turnover, the cost of recruiting versus training versus internal moves, the success rate of onboarding, and how long it takes. Then involve business teams in your work, inviting them to work alongside you in investigating turnover rates, pipeline problems, or onboarding results.Be a helper and be a problem-solver, said McFarland. “Even if your team is split up between a people experience side and a talent side, talent acquisition specialists can be the ear for another team member, even if they just need someone to vent to or help them through difficulty or bounce an idea off of.”“They have to first see you as a partner that they can trust,” Moll said. “That takes time, and that means building relationships a little bit at a time, and that means maybe not participating in workforce planning this year, but you’re building to be part of it the next one.” The good news, McFarland noted, is that the relationship between HR and business is already becoming more strategic, and the direction of travel is positive.“Workforce planning is a tool, not a result. It’s not about having the perfect plan. That doesn’t exist,” Moll said. A plan is a guide. When you have a guide, you can adapt when things change. And things will always change.Editor's note: From Day One thanks our partner, HiBob, for sponsoring this webinar. Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza is a freelance journalist and From Day One contributing editor who writes about work, the job market, and women’s experiences in the workplace. Her work has appeared in the Economist, the BBC, The Washington Post, Quartz, Fast Company, and Digiday’s Worklife.

Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza | September 30, 2024