Help Wanted: Tools for Solving the Hourly-worker Shortage

BY Sheila Flynn | August 18, 2021

From highway billboards advertising jobs at McDonald’s to regional ads on movie theater screens trying to attract workers to Shutterfly, the push to recruit hourly employees has reached something of a zenith across the U.S. And there’s good reason for that.

As Covid vaccination rates increase and the U.S. economy recovers, fewer and fewer people are looking to start back up at their old jobs. Both surveys and anecdotal evidence indicate that many workers, including those paid hourly, are no longer satisfied to return to industries that proved particularly vulnerable during a pandemic, including the hospitality industry. Some workers have learned new skills, decided to switch careers, or simply searched for better and different opportunities.

That’s left a hole for many employers looking to fill hourly-wage positions, with employers facing a level of competition that hasn’t been seen for decades–or possibly ever. “I’ve been doing this for close to 40 years. I have never seen this type of market during last Q4 in my lifetime. We were able to meet the hiring demands, but we struggled with that,” said Peggy Anderson, head of talent acquisition at Shutterfly, during a recent From Day One webinar titled “Solving the Hourly-Worker Shortage Using Recruiting Tech and Data.”

Employers have responded with a range of tools, including the use of AI to place job ads and virtual job interviews on Zoom, but they also still rely on techniques that are “a little old-fashioned,” as Anderson put it. While the tech tools facilitate the search and vetting process, some managers remain loathe to onboard frontline or hourly employees without first getting to meet them in person.

“I really want to emphasize that speed is not everything,” said Kerry Royer, head of global talent acquisition for Verizon, adding that “it’s making sure you keep a human in the process, too, because there’s a lot of things you can do in your process to hire people in a week–let technology do it right for you all the way through–but we believe at Verizon that there should be a human in the process.”

Speaking on the hourly-worker shortage, top row from left: Kyle Leigh of Appcast and Peggy Anderson of Shutterfly. Bottow row, from left, Kerry Royer of Verizon, moderator Lydia Dishman of Fast Company and Marshela McDaniel of McDonald's (Image by From Day One)

At the same time, however, the current demand for hourly workers everywhere from fast-food chains to Amazon means that, to some extent, now it’s the employers who need to compete with each other, rather than the candidates. So even if employers aren’t making snap decisions about prospective hires, they need to be responsive. “Just responding to the applicant the same day is huge,” said Kyle Leigh of Appcast, which makes software for programmatic job advertising. “If you’re Applebees and you get a candidate for a line cook, that line cook needs a job yesterday, right? That person is not going to wait two to three days to hear back from you.” The candidate will go elsewhere, like Amazon. The immediacy is the “biggest challenge that our clients get,” Leigh added.

“It’s a competitive market,” confirmed Marshela McDaniel, a field people officer for McDonald’s. “If people are looking to apply, they’re not just looking at one location, they’re looking at multiple locations and trying to understand, Who’s going to get back to me? Which is going to give me the best opportunity to fit my needs as an employee?”

“We’ve been able to really reduce that time-to-hire process,” she added. “Right now, we’re roughly at about eight days. And we’re continuing to see improvements in those numbers. And so our goal is going to be to continue to create that experience where not only does the employee feel engaged in the process, but we’re really able to really set that great first impression in that hiring process.”

On top of finding candidates in the first place, many companies have added sweeteners to seal the deal: better pay, signing bonus incentives, more flexible hours, additional benefits, and a more curated overall image of their corporate culture. “A lot of our operators have joined into the sign-on bonus idea to try to help attract and bring in people quickly,” McDaniel said. “Many of our operators are looking at flexibility in regards to scheduling, understanding that we do serve a population that many people either go to school or they have a second job or maybe they’re supporting and serving their family.” She added: “Many of our operators have looked at various additional benefits, such as maybe free or discounted meals, free or discounted uniforms. Really, they’re trying to appeal to the community in which they serve.”

That involves casting an even more thoughtful eye on forums for advertising, wording of job postings, and general demographics when it comes to prospective workers, participants said. “When you look at restaurant and retail workers, about half of the population, historically, have been women,” Appcast’s Leigh said. “And that is exactly the population that left the workforce to take care of children, take care of elderly parents.”

“That said, there are keywords in job descriptions that you should be cognizant of, gender-coded keywords, male-coded keywords like ‘superior,’ like ‘decision,’ ‘confident,’ vs. female-coded words like ‘interpersonal,’ ‘cooperative,’ ‘warm,’” he said, pointing out that such phrases can dissuade and “turn off certain folks who’ve read those descriptions.”

Another consideration is focusing on a company’s employee-focused initiatives, which can make an employer more attractive. At Verizon, for example, the company’s hiring rate fell to essentially zero when the pandemic hit, but the telecom giant focused on redeploying retail and other workers to more immediate jobs within the corporation, rather than laying off or furloughing staff, Royer said. She continued: “We really doubled down on how we showed up during Covid. We had Covid sick leave where we paid them 100% of pay for up to eight weeks and 60% of pay for 16 weeks, really just showing how, in unstable times, we showed up.”

Now that hiring has picked up, Verizon’s Royer said, the company’s track record can help attract more quality candidates. Frontline workers, she said, are “often really interested in, what is my opportunity for moving up in the company? What are you going to do to develop me?” she said. “And so we really focus, in our messaging, on the importance of, ‘There is a career path here for you.’”

Sheila Flynn is a Denver-based journalist who has written for the Associated Press, Bloomberg News, the Sunday Independent, and the Irish Daily Mail. She is a graduate of the University of Notre Dame.


RELATED STORIES

Aligning Learning Programs With Business Strategy for Global Workforce Agility

Businesses are placing more demands on learning and development teams, says Jamie O’Brien, AVP of learning and development at investment platform Voya Financial. Most importantly, “keeping learners engaged in a rapidly changing environment, and aligning our learning programs with our business objectives,” she said during a From Day One webinar. The pace of change gets faster every year.“We’re no longer designing and delivering training solutions just for different adult learning styles, but also for virtual and hybrid work environments, with rapidly changing technology, and for five generations of workers,” she said.Voya’s learners are increasingly seeking an experiential environment. They don’t want to sit through lectures, O’Brien says. “They want to do it. They want to try it. They want to feel it. They want to feel like they’ve been prepared and they’re confident in their ability to come out of training and then go do their roles.”Fellow panelist Tim Gerrits agreed: Leaders in L&D now do much more than transfer information. Gerrits is the the head of learning and leadership development at pharmaceutical company AbbVie, thinks about application most of all.“As it becomes easier to find whatever snippet of knowledge you need, that’s no longer the real crux of success for organizations,” he said. “It’s not putting information into people’s heads, it’s how you get that information back out and change behavior.” Lynnette Collins, head of global L&D at office furniture manufacturer Steelcase, identified the “most difficult part, and the most critical part,” of her job: “Making the connection between those goals, our learning experiences, and key performance indicators.” Who completed the training and when is not nearly as relevant to the executives as how they’re helping the business grow.Yet it’s not easy to demonstrate the value of L&D, said Ken Matos, director of market insights at HiBob, an HR management platform. Returns may not happen right away and even if they do, learners may need help identifying just how they’re applying their new skills. As businesses become more complex, so do learning outcomes, and measurement follows suit.Journalist Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza moderated the panel of experts (photo by From Day One)Ultimately, leaders have to be able to feel the difference, not just see it on paper, says Matos. “Being able to change the stakeholders’ impression of what’s happening in the organization is one of your best, most accessible outcomes, because they are the ones who said it was a problem to begin with. And if they’re not feeling that problem anymore, you have succeeded. Being able to articulate that back to them is a really powerful message.”At AbbVie, Gerrits invites those leading business functions to observe learning in progress at assessment centers. “They see what we’re doing and the transformation that’s taking place with participants, and that gives them confidence that what we’re doing–not only in that assessment center, but overall–is important for the organization.”When Steelcase’s new CEO Sara Armbruster took the role three years ago, “she introduced a long-term strategy for growth, which was new for us in the organization,” Collins said. In the first year, Collins’s team contacted the top 400 global leaders in the company to ask what skills and behaviors they believe are necessary to achieve those new goals, and what might get in the way.“At first, our measurement was really around improving leader perception on how we perform these transformation behaviors,” Collins said. “But now we’re going a bit deeper, because we want to connect it to performance. Ultimately, we want these behaviors to become the way we work to achieve our results.”O’Brien knows her L&D programs are really working when they create a buzz, and managers–or individual contributors–come asking to participate or partner in the design. She knocks on doors, too, to find out whether teams feel that they’re benefitting. If they don’t seem engaged, “that’s a chance for me to ask questions about what their goals are and get closer to what it is that we can deliver.”Business goals can change quickly–just think of how many employers rushed to incorporate some kind of AI into their workflows–and priorities may migrate up or down the list. To stay relevant, L&D needs to change along with them.Editor's note: From Day One thanks our partner, HiBob, for sponsoring this webinar. Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza is a freelance journalist and From Day One contributing editor who writes about work, the job market, and women’s experiences in the workplace. Her work has appeared in the Economist, the BBC, The Washington Post, Inc., Quartz, Business Insider, Fast Company, and Digiday’s Worklife.

Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza | January 29, 2025

Redefining Skills: How Skills Assessment Data Can Give You The Strategic Advantage

Organizations are embracing AI and cutting-edge technologies to revolutionize skills assessment, unlocking powerful insights that drive competitive advantage. With 90% of companies expecting a major shift in required skills within the next three years, staying ahead has never been more critical.Using new technology, organizations can effectively diversify their skills assessment data collection. More efficiently than before, companies can identify leadership and talent skills for talent acquisition, personalized learning, reskilling, succession planning, and internal mobility.During a From Day One webinar, a panel of talent and learning and development leaders shared their experiences of implementing a variety of skills assessments to measure skills, reskill, and improve employee performance.Using Assessments to Propel Workers ForwardLucy Beaumont, a solution lead, manager and leader at SHL, shared three ways most organizations collect data The first is using a form of self-report, manager report, or 360 assessment to obtain subjective data. Next, AI data assessments quickly and objectively sort and analyze internal data to measure and summarize employees’ current skills, skill gaps, and potential. Lastly, personalized behavioral assessments thoroughly uncover an employee or leader’s current strengths and skill gaps.Erin Freshwater, head of learning, talent, and organizational development at Hormel Foods, described the company’s innovative approach to collecting personalized skills assessment data. “Fom our leadership pipeline perspective, it’s been really important that we understand what are the skills that our leaders have in order to lead our teams and our organization into the future,” Freshwater said.Hormel Foods takes their officer-level group through 8-hour-long simulations. Then, psychologists assess their leadership skills. They identify the group’s skill gaps, assess them, give feedback to leadership development, and implement them into development programs for future company leadership.The panelists discussed "Redefining Skills: How Skills Assessment Data Can Give You The Strategic Advantage" during the webinar (photo by From Day One)Stephanie Ketron, head of learning and development director at Westgate Resorts, spoke about using data-driven and personalized assessments. First, the company assesses an employee’s inventory of skills. After their skills are rated, they proceed to individual curriculums based on their skill sets.Leaders then review an employee’s skill gaps identified through their individual assessment and design a personalized development plan tailored to their needs. Ketron emphasized the importance of avoiding a one-size-fits-all approach, noting that even employees in the same role may possess different skill sets.Westgate Resorts has seen this data-driven and personalized skill assessment approach achieve positive business outcomes. However, traditional self-report assessments still create efficient data that can be combined with data from other assessments later on.Julian Allen, director of global talent management at MiTek, discussed the continuing effectiveness of 360 assessments. After creating a strategic plan with company leaders, MiTek refers to external resources to pinpoint the skills needed to achieve business outcomes. Then, by using 360 assessments, they create individual employee development programs to learn the necessary skills.The personalization of these programs is evident, initially only for employees to progress in their internal mobility without input from managers. Now, MiTek is shifting to using 360 assessments for overall talent planning.Ultimately, companies using a variety of assessments improve their hiring processes, Allen says. “So be that job simulations, personality assessments, and multiple different tools that are out there, I think that gives us additional data to make an informed decision,” he said.Skills for Future-Proof JobsWhat are other factors employers consider when determining the specific skills employees should learn? How are employers building roadmaps for employees to learn those skills to advance in their careers?SHL provides data-driven insights to help organizations enhance their hiring, development, and talent mobility strategies. Drawing from client feedback, SHL highlights that reskilling is a critical need across all industries. Beaumont says that reskilling has become a common priority for SHL clients, particularly as industries evolve and integrate new technologies.“As soon as you start your job, it’s going to change and you’re going to have to learn something new. And then from an L&D perspective, we’re just constantly trying to get people up to speed. Whether it’s with new technologies or new ways of working,” Beaumont said.Soft skills are still relevant. However, they are developed differently. Ketron expressed how emotional and cultural intelligence or interpersonal relationship skills are crucial. Yet, these skills aren’t quantifiable. “I think sometimes those are a lot harder as a skill set to kind of measure and determine, and we put very clear behavioral identifiers to those,” she said.Paul Jung, senior director of people experience at Optum, emphasized the significance of technological skills in the healthcare organization. Their clinical key talent group sets a precedent for existing and incoming talent.Using AI, Optum assesses the entirety of company data to identify skill opportunities and gaps, aligning them with business goals, and creating talent pipelines. As AI serves an integral role in managing mass employee data, personalization and a humanistic approach to other skill development remains a necessity. “They don’t want the machines to tell them where they should go next,” Jung said.For example, at Hormel, employees work with a coach for 6-9 months after completing their behavioral assessments. This has proven effective for the company, Freshwater says. Therefore, data-driven skills assessments with peer and leader mentorship for soft skills continue to achieve better business outcomes.Moderator Lydia Dishman, senior editor at Fast Company, summarized using hard data with human mentorship to redefine skills and boost development. “You do need the human component, but you do have this partnership with artificial intelligence in order to put whatever you’re doing up a notch,” Dishman said.Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, SHL, for sponsoring this webinar. Stephanie Reed is a freelance news, marketing, and content writer. Much of her work features small business owners throughout diverse industries. She is passionate about promoting small, ethical, and eco-conscious businesses.

Stephanie Reed | January 28, 2025

Mental Health in the Workplace: Creating an Environment of Care

Untreated mental health issues cost U.S. businesses over $300 billion annually, but investing in mental health initiatives like EAPs, peer support, and mindfulness programs can significantly reduce costs, boost productivity, and improve employee well-being.In fact, the Harvard Business Review found that peer support programs improve employee mental health outcomes by 35% and of course, they increase feelings of belonging by 40% and companies with mental health incentives experience, says Lydia Dishman, senior editor of growth and engagement at Fast Company, who moderated a session on mental health in the workplace during a From Day One’s webinar.Clearly, there is a lot companies can do to help improve the mental health of its employees. Here’s how the five panelists suggested organizations create environments of care.Trends in Employee CareMore and more, employees are asking employers for needs like financial help, housing issues, food insecurity, as well as mental health, according to panelist Nicole Roger, director of clinical partnerships at Spring Health. “Creating a culture of care really makes sure that we help people and meet them where they’re at,” she said. Unfortunately, many times people have too many hoops to jump through the more help they need. It’s important to pay attention and not let employees fall through the cracks.When employees need mental health care and help paying their electric bill, or help with their next meal, that’s going to affect them as a person and as an employee. Employees are asking for more support, and employers should be ready to answer. “I’m really proud that Spring Health has been able to embed that into our platform. So not only can you see a therapist, but we’ll ask you, hey, are you having trouble paying your electric bill?” Then they can help connect them with services to make that happen, Roger said.Those in HR need to understand that they aren’t the therapists—they just need to know where the therapists are and how to connect employees with what they need. “It’s okay for us as human beings to say, I actually don’t know,” she said. “But you know what? I’m going to help. I’m going to help get you this answer. It just creates that element of authenticity.”Panelists spoke about mental health care in the workplace (photo by From Day One) The first time anyone asks for help can feel extra scary, so Roger suggested removing words like “mental health” so it feels more like a conversation. Instead ask, “How are you feeling physically? Are you stressed out? How’s your sleep?”One thing companies should consider is using vendors who use measurement-based care, so you can track if employees are getting the help they need.Checking In: Are You Okay?The first step can be as simple as asking the question, “Are you okay?” according to panelist Melinda Morimoto, senior benefits director at Genentech. “At the end of the day, our people need to know that we care about them as individuals. So what that looks like for me with my team, we start our staff meetings with a poll. How are you doing mentally? What’s your workload?” The answers will drive the meeting and help them course correct. Because the biggest challenge is leaders looking the other way. But doing nothing doesn’t help the employee that’s struggling.Genentech created a network of 400 mental health champions across the U.S. with the idea of spreading mental health awareness across the organization and reducing stigma. For the entire month of May, they wore “Are You OK?” t-shirts, but people kept wearing them after that. It offered a signal that they were in a safe space—that you can be connected to resources.“I had an employee who lost her mom and her sister and then was struggling with her dependent,” Morimoto said. “I said, ‘well, have you reached out for help and scheduled therapy? It’s free.’” The person responded that things weren’t that bad. “‘Well, how bad does it have to be before you reach out for help?’”Unmet needs can quickly escalate, so it’s vital to keep up-to-date on what employees need. At Genentech, they surveyed their people and found the number one gap was caring for aging parents. They responded to that need by including a caregiver benefit with coaches who did the homework to find options for the aging parent and offer help for the employee. “It gives them back time. It gives them back peace of mind that they're doing the best that they can,” she added.Another thing they’ve done is to embed resource groups within the business. Sometimes, Morimoto says, it’s easier to relate to someone more like you within the employee community. Not only that but making getting mental health access as easy as possible was a priority.“One of the things that we did that was really powerful is we actually put a mental health clinician right by the manufacturing floor with accessibility for drop in.” That way, there was no waiting for help, no searching for help. It was literally a step away. “I am in the moment struggling, and I want help. It’s right in that door.”Meeting Employees Where They AreJudgment-free care is key to good mental health in the workplace, said panelist Melanie Baxter, director of global wellbeing at Alorica.“We have over 140,000 incredible employees internationally, and my job is to make sure they’re cared for,” Baxter said. “I’m their landing pad.” She added that the only way to move forward is to not attach judgment or labels to people. The important part is opening up that dialogue.“I’m seeing this so much more in workplaces where the dialogue is ‘You don’t have to be the solution granter. You don't have to be all things to all people. You just have to be the landing pad or even the starting place.’”Word choice is important so people feel comfortable. In her position, Baxter likes to say, “I noticed” to open up the conversation. “I think if you can say, first I noticed this again, it removes that judgment, it removes that attachment.” It allows true feelings to emerge, she says.She also utilizes the Wellness Wheel approach, which addresses all aspects of well-being, including mental, physical, financial, social, familial, and environmental. It uses data and tools like EAP (employee assistance programs) to address the needs of employees.“When I joined Alorica, I was really gifted with focus groups, and there’s such a culture of transparency,” Baxter said. “I asked in my focus groups, what’s in the way?” Laying the groundwork and building the culture is key to being able to have open conversations. What can be in the way, however, is not having people who look like you or understand you that you can talk to.“What I have found, and what I want to encourage anyone on this call right now, is to be rigorous with your vendors,” she said. “I have found incredible mental health practitioner partners that offer gender affirming mental health care, which was something I never even knew was that hard to track down, and it’s not any more expensive. You just have to ask.” she said. “You’ve got to be willing to ask questions, willing to hear the answers, and then you’ve got to act on the answers.”Addressing Barriers and BiasPanelist DeShawna Manley, national benefits director at PriceWaterHouseCoopers, tries to understand what motivates people. “Understanding not only what someone is good at, but what they want to learn, it helps them to enable their work life to be more fulfilling,” she said.One of her jobs is helping to bridge gaps by involving representatives who employees can relate to, whether based on race, gender, or other factors. “I’ve had HR managers who could not connect, and I’ve asked, ‘Do you mind if I reach out?’ Because sometimes seeing someone on the other side of that screen that looks like you will create that connection,” Manely said. “It’s human for us to have certain comfort levels with certain people.”There’s another type of bias she sees, and that’s unconscious generational bias. It could be older leaders who don’t understand younger workers who think differently. As Manely says, it all starts with awareness. “I’ve had conversations with the more Gen X leaders, and they don’t understand the behavior of the Gen Zer,” As someone on the cusp of Gen X and Millenial, she understood. “Being able to say, I can relate to your perspective. I understand where you’re coming from. I understand that this new generation, this younger generation, they operate differently, their perspective, their needs, are a little different.With that conversation, the light bulb will go off and there is an awareness of unconscious bias that helps everyone move forward.Diversity of care is important, and finding vendors that offer access to what employees need is key. The less barriers to care, the better, she says.Engagement and AuthenticityBenefits means more now than ever, said panelist Christopher Smith, vice president of benefits at Universal Music Group. You have to engage and be authentic in order to help them. You have to leave your desk and talk to people and truly listen.“Get up and talk to some folks. The folks are your stakeholders. They are your clients. If you want to know what somebody wants, sometimes you have to ask. And that, I think, has been the secret to my success as a benefits leader,” Smith said.A big part of listening is then acting on what employees need. Even if that changes over time. “I think there is a lot of stigma behind thinking, I have a job. I'm making X amount of dollars a year, so I shouldn’t have a financial problem. It’s embarrassing to go and talk to somebody about these things, right?” Smith said. But that shouldn’t be the case. Especially when being unable to have these real discussions causes stress. “So I think being able to have real conversations and share a little bit of our humanity can go a long way,” he said.By fostering open conversations, reducing stigma, and meeting employees where they are, companies can create cultures of care that not only improve well-being but also drive engagement, productivity, and retention. The key is listening to employees, acting on their needs, and ensuring access to diverse, judgment-free resources that support every aspect of their lives.Carrie Snider is a Phoenix-based journalist and marketing copywriter.

Carrie Snider | January 03, 2025