Why Improving Frontline Jobs May Be Your Company’s Ticket to Success–or Survival

BY Matthew Koehler | October 04, 2023

In the midst of several years of environmental, social, and economic upheavals, including the lasting effects of Covid on the workforce, consumers and workers have been pulling companies toward conscious capitalism. And while companies have been pulled, that isn’t the denouement of this story. 

Recently at a property summit in Australia, Tim Gurner expounded upon the need for there to be pain in the economy and for companies to flip the script on workers. Namely, workers should be afraid and feel lucky for their jobs, not the other way around. 

This seems to be the opposite direction of where companies should be going according to Zeynep Ton, a professor at MIT’s Sloan School of Management and author of The Case for Good Jobs: How Great Companies Bring Dignity, Pay, and Meaning to Everyone’s Work. 

“A good job could mean different things to different people. Right sense of belonging, achievements, purpose, recognition are all the ingredients,” Ton said, but there are “minimum conditions that all companies should have.” 

“Those minimum conditions are first, very obviously, being treated like a human with brains with a heart, not just a pair of hands. And then the second one is for pay to be high enough so that people can take control over their lives.” 

Ton was interviewed by Editor in Chief of the Harvard Business Review, Adi Ignatius. They spoke at a recent From Day One fireside chat in Boston. 

Market Rate Pay vs. the Good Jobs Strategy 

Taking a step back, Ignatius pointed out that Ton actually wrote two books about jobs, her current one The Case for Good Jobs and her previous The Good Jobs Strategy. In The Good Jobs Strategy, Ton used the low cost retail market as an example of how companies make a choice on two different ways to operate. Companies can choose to offer low wages, have low productivity, and high turnover rates. This is a “bad job strategy” according to Ton.

“The other world is to pay employees a lot more than competitors do, offer them better benefits, and design the job for high productivity, high contribution, and operate with low employee turnover, great customer service, and more,” Ton said. 

Ignatius brought up the fact that a lot of CEOs “care about the planet” per se, but don’t pay mind to labor issues. 

“It’s always amazing to me that some leaders talk about conscious capitalism, but when it comes to their frontline workers,” Ton said, are “completely fine with below subsistence wages” and all the problems that arise from it. She points to generations of business leaders being taught that “market pay is the right pay” and says the market pay mentality is driven by the idea that “labor is just another cost of production that is just like any other input.”  

“And when we think about inputs to production, the right pay is the market pay. So because people are just another cost, we should pay market wages. And paying market wages is so dominant, that people can’t even imagine operating any differently.”

Zeynep Ton, author of The Case for Good Jobs was interviewed in the grand finale session in Boston (company photo)

Using Costco as an example, Ton says co-founder Jim Sinegal comes to her classes every year to address students and his message is: Of course, you pay people more. “Because you understand that when people can’t focus on the job, turnover is going to be high. And now there’s so much research that shows that low pay is associated with all sorts of health costs. It even lowers cognitive functioning, low pay is equivalent to a 13 point reduction in IQ.”

Ton says the resistance to higher pay is short-sighted. Low pay and high turnover leads directly to high turnover costs. 

“We have worked with organizations, frontline organizations, and we’ve seen turnover levels, anywhere from 40% to 400%. So the direct costs are recruiting, hiring, onboarding, time to productivity training. Those costs can be 10 to 25% of the total labor payroll spent annually.” Turnover costs pale in comparison to other financial costs, like lost sales, mistakes, lower productivity, lower quality. 

Why isn’t higher pay being adopted?

Ton gave three reasons why she believes leadership is resistant to making the better pay change.

“There’s a lack of imagination that there could be another world. And one of the things that makes imagination very difficult is a lot of organizations make their decisions, looking at just numbers. And oftentimes, they work in silos, and they look at the history and what happened in the past. And that prevents them from imagining any other possibility going forward,” Ton said.

Secondly, leadership has a long laundry list of priorities, with board members and stakeholders being top priority and high turnover and the cost of high turnover being much lower. “The investors and board [are] not asking you about what’s your turnover? What’s your cost of turnover? How good is your customer satisfaction?” Given all that leadership has to deal with, accepting high turnover, and its costs, are simply easier.

“The playbook for a good job strategy is harder than the playbook of pay as low as possible. In the good job system, you pay high. You design the work, which means you cross train your employees. You empower them to make decisions. You make their work better. You pay attention to staffing levels, so they can come up with improvement ideas.”

The third reason these changes aren’t more commonplace is both a lack of conversation on the topic and a misplaced lack of trust between management and staff. 

“When they are stuck in their own vicious cycle of poverty, because pay is so low, they have all sorts of problems, cognitive problems, health problems. They’re not performing well on the job.” Ton says management incorrectly equates this to a lack of capability on the part of the worker. 
“Well, I can’t trust you, because you show up late. I can’t trust you, because you just yelled at the customer. So how am I going to empower you to make decisions? How am I going to invest in you?” Ton said.

AI as an Answer

Before stepping off the stage, Ignatius asked Ton what she thought about AI’s impact on labor. 

“I think it really depends on how we use technology, right? Technology doesn’t have an effect. Technology’s effect on work and workers will depend on how we use our imagination to deploy technology,” Ton said. 

Turning to the example of Sam’s Club, Ton described how they were able to use technology to better utilize staff, raise salaries, and improve the customer experience. She gives the example of purchasing a tire for your car several years ago versus now, a process that used to take 20 minutes or more. “Now with technology that processes just a few minutes. That means that the associate, instead of wasting their time looking through different manuals, can focus on the customer. They can ask you for ID. What are you using your car for? What performance are you most interested in? Do you want a low cost?” They are now better advocates for their customers. “And because their job is a lot more productive. Sam’s Club can pay them more.”

So what should business leaders talk about the next time they find themselves at Davos, for example?

“Instead of talking about other things, people at Davos should be talking about pay. And make sure that everybody makes a living wage,” Ton said.

Matthew Koheler is a freelance journalist and licensed real estate agent based in Washington, DC. His work has appeared in Greater Greater Washington, The Washington Post, The Southwester, and Walking Cinema, among others.

RELATED STORIES

How Innovative Employers Are Elevating Internal Mobility

The workforce landscape is constantly evolving, and companies must rethink traditional approaches to talent development. Internal mobility, the ability for employees to transition into new roles within the same organization, has become a vital strategy for addressing skills shortages, fostering employee engagement, and driving long-term retention. A panel of experts shared insights into how businesses can boost internal mobility at From Day One’s Live Austin’s conference, in a session moderated by Kathryn Lundstrom, commerce and sustainability editor of Adweek.Upskilling Current EmployeesHiring new people can’t always happen as quickly as you'd like, and the workforce may not always have the exact skills needed. Panelist Jeannie Steele, head of global talent acquisition at AMD, an AI product company, discussed the importance of internal mobility.“We found ourselves in a situation where we needed to quickly find thousands of engineers, and we couldn’t find them externally. Our leaders decided that if there was a 70% skills match, we would move some of our current employees into those roles,” Steele said. Through this strategy, AMD filled about half of its urgently needed AI positions in less than a month—all with existing employees. The company also focuses on internal development through its Luminary Series, a monthly upskilling program where corporate fellows teach classes to engineers, sharing knowledge and best practices in real time.While internal mobility is key, Steele emphasized the importance of fresh perspectives: “Our leadership team set a goal for 2024 that 40% of our hires this year should be early talent, defined as zero to five years of experience.”Retention, however, remains a challenge. How can organizations keep employees engaged? The answer lies in learning opportunities. “We’ve been using technology to train on AI skills. We’re upskilling our talent through a LinkedIn enterprise package for everyone,” Steele said. Employees can choose their own learning paths, benefiting both the company and the individual.Rethinking EducationCareer paths no longer follow a clear, linear trajectory. How can companies help employees upskill for non-linear careers? Panelist Stephanie Ricks, director of corporate development and technology partnerships at Strategic Education, emphasized the need to rethink education.“Talent acquisition professionals are tasked with creating the link between education and career navigation, and then selling that to potential candidates,” Ricks said.Today, career growth doesn’t follow a straight ladder—it’s more like a rock-climbing wall, shifting sideways as it ascends. Companies can adapt by repurposing an underutilized benefit: education. While tuition assistance is a common benefit, its usage remains low, often hovering around 3%, signaling a need for policy updates. Instead of limiting how employees can use these benefits, companies can broaden their scope.Strategic Education addressed this by developing Workforce Edge, a SaaS platform providing access to everything from GEDs to certifications to PhDs. “Employees can leverage those dollars you give them, empowering them to take learning into their own hands,” Ricks said. Empowering employees in this way not only builds their careers but also fosters loyalty.Panelists spoke about "Creating Opportunity Within: How Employers Are Boosting Internal Mobility" at From Day One's Austin conferenceNon-traditional education platforms also offer flexibility. Traditional course curricula often take months, or years, to be approved, by which time the business’s needs may have already shifted. Companies can help shape learning opportunities tailored to their evolving needs. For example, Ricks helped develop Tech Inspire, a program designed to upskill employees in areas like cybersecurity, generative AI, and other emerging tech fields.“We go out, find the talent, and work with you to shape the curriculum to ensure hard skills are covered,” Ricks said.Improving Mental Health Through LearningContinued education should be seen as a holistic part of employee benefits, according to Emil Kresl, director of learning and development at The University of Texas at Austin.“Research shows that learning can reduce symptoms of depression and fend off dementia,” Kresl said. Employees engaged in learning often report higher levels of happiness and optimism.“There’s something about learning that builds community, and that all ties into health and well-being,” he said. “In the past, learning and development were focused on increasing productivity. Now, we understand that it’s not just about upskilling—it's about supporting mental health. It should be an essential part of the benefits package.”A culture of continuous learning is key to making this approach successful. Without an organizational-wide commitment, employees may not prioritize it. “You want people to be curious and explore, to find out where they can have the greatest impact,” Kresl said. “But you need to make continuous learning a core part of your culture.”While hard skills can be taught, Kresl emphasized that fostering employees’ aptitude for learning and agility is what enables them to thrive.Offering Collaboration and SupportThe shelf life of skills is shorter than ever, making internal mobility crucial. Panelist Tiana Carter, AVP of Human Resources at USAA, emphasized the importance of collaboration and support in fostering long-term employees.“At USAA, we offer free college for both employees and their dependents,” Carter said, noting that generations of families appreciate this opportunity. However, some skills must be developed after college. USAA’s Skills Marketplace initiative offers a solution for their engineering team. “Our tech teams can test and learn new skills in real time, while still in their current roles, so they can transition into new, emerging jobs,” Carter said. “It’s a nice transitional period.”With 25% of USAA’s workforce being military-affiliated, upskilling is a priority, as veterans often experience high turnover in search of long-term careers. USAA recently launched a Military Leadership Development Program, where senior military personnel rotate through various lines of business to explore potential career paths. Plus, they get 18 months of guidance and advocacy to ensure veterans find their home in the organization.Internal mobility is more than just a strategy for addressing skill gaps—it’s an opportunity to empower employees and foster organizational agility. By offering new pathways for growth and development, companies not only adapt to changing workforce demands but also inspire loyalty and innovation in their teams.Carrie Snider is a Phoenix-based journalist and marketing copywriter.

Carrie Snider | December 16, 2024

In an Argumentative Time, How to Create Healthy Conversations at Work and in Life

The most recent election points to America, and many parts of the world, being divided. Now more than ever, we should prioritize fostering constructive dialogue over casting blame. In a sense, we need more peacemakers.“Once we free ourselves from the fiction that anyone who disagrees with us must be a monster or a fool, we need not be so afraid of allowing ourselves to be persuaded,” wrote Steven T. Collis, a Constitutional Law professor at the University of Texas, in his most recent book, Habits of a Peacemaker.Collis spoke to KVUE sports journalist Cory Mose at From Day One’s Austin conference. They discussed the habits of peacemakers that allow for sometimes difficult, but fruitful conversations.Understanding the Limits of What You KnowCollis is a First Amendment law professor who specializes in freedom of speech and religion, and is no stranger to difficult conversations on a broad range of topics. He’s been thinking about how to more effectively have those conversations for a while. “I travel all over the globe talking about those really controversial topics. And I started to ask myself what is it that we’re doing that’s allowing us to have productive conversations about these really difficult topics? When most people just devolve into shouting matches and arguments."Collis’ mission isn’t just navigating difficult conversations in politics and culture. His aim is to offer non-partisan tactics for dealing with all sorts of conversations, often drawing on anecdotes from his own life. “The book was about how to have productive conversations about hard topics. We see them in our family dynamics. We see them in the workplace. We see them at schools, at churches, anywhere where [you] have to deal with another person, difficult conversations come up.”Drawing from his book, he started with intellectual humility and tells the story of his middle school days of looking cool. One day, he confidently strolled into the bathroom and spiked his hair with what he thought was mousse. Strutting out of the bathroom, his mom caught a whiff of his head and immediately marched him back in and washed his hair out. “It turns out that what I thought was moose was actually her hair removal product, Nair. And for the next week, all my hair started falling out. For the rest of the summer, people thought I had some horrible illness.”“We get in trouble in life when we think we know about something and we don’t, and we have strong feelings about it. Intellectual humility is critical.”Collis, left, spoke about his book Habits of a Peacemaker: 10 Habits to Change Our Potentially Toxic Conversations into Healthy DialoguesIn a heated debate, we’re all experts. Especially if we’ve learned a little bit about something, then we’re not only experts, but we form very concrete opinions. “Scientists call this the Dunning Kruger effect, and it’s been pretty well established,” Collis said.At the University of Michigan Law School, a frieze above one of the doorways features a pertinent inscription: “a little learning is a dangerous thing; drink deep or taste not.” Collis often walked through this door. “That has become ingrained in my mind as something to remember. Now the question is, how do we establish that in ourselves?”Compounding the Dunning Kruger effect is that most of us walk around “enjoying something called the knowledge illusion,” or a bias in which we think we understand more than we do. “Any one of us actually knows almost nothing,” Collis said.A senior business leader he recently talked to shared that recognizing how little he knows and how much he can learn from his team has been vital to his success. By fostering open communication and encouraging input, he ensures his position doesn’t intimidate others, creating space for growth and collaboration.Asking yourself that same question: ‘How much do I actually know about this,’ is a good way to remind yourself of how little you actually know, says Collis.The Root of the Argument“I know it’s hard for a lot of people to do. But one thing that stuck out to me, was how you explain the surface level argument that you may be having with someone may not be the root of why you’re having that discussion,” Mose said.This touches on something Collis finds true of all effective peacemakers. One of their enduring habits is that if someone “come[s] in really hot about something,” peacemakers assume a good motivation for why their interlocutor acts or thinks the way they do. “Most of us strut around the world thinking, there’s three kinds of people: there’s the people who agree with us, and then there are monsters and fools. Peacemakers don’t do that.”Peacemakers realize that their disagreeable interlocutor has a position they have to better understand. Perhaps they have the same goals but differ on how to achieve them. That’s a valuable conversation to have. Or, perhaps your goals are different, yet another worthy conversation there.“There are bad actors, but generally speaking, in our families and our work lives and the day to day people we’re having contact with, it’s not a good practice to start off assuming the absolute worst about somebody.”Another quality of peacemakers that Collis admittedly doesn't have in spades, is spending time with people. In the workplace, for example, Collis says it applies to work relationships as well. “Spending time with your colleagues in a way where you’re just building the relationship and you’re not dealing with the hard topics, allows the later conversations that will inevitably come that are difficult to be far more productive.”None of this is easy, though, and Collis says people can spend a lifetime perfecting the good habits of a peacemaker.“I can’t emphasize enough the idea that the ideas in this book are ones that we could all spend a lifetime perfecting. Nobody has perfected any of these things, and I don’t mean the book to be exhaustive. I would encourage people to take the skills that they already have and add [to] them.”An important message going forward, and one derived from the pages of Collis’ book, is also simple but hard to do. Peacemakers need to have the ability to change and adapt to new information.“Being a peacemaker carries with it important responsibilities. One of which is being willing to change. This is a hard concept for humanity to understand. But recognizing that we don’t know everything, and being willing to learn, seeking the best sources for doing so, asking people honest questions, all of those mean nothing if you’re unwilling to ponder the new things you are learning and consider changing your views.”Matthew Koehler is a freelance journalist and licensed real estate agent based in Washington, DC. His work has appeared in Greater Greater Washington, The Washington Post, The Southwester, and Walking Cinema, among others.

Matthew Koehler | December 11, 2024

Supporting Equity Through Workplace Well-Being

It’s no secret that for many American workers, times are tough. In fact, almost 80% are living paycheck-to-paycheck. And 49% of employees are finding it difficult to meet monthly household expenses, Penelope Talbot-Kelly, VP and GM, B2B at EarnIn, shared during a panel discussion at From Day One’s Austin conference.With workers feeling the financial burden, emotional stress is sure to follow, with work performance potentially feeling the impact. Fortunately, there are tangible ways employers can provide support. Panelists shared some of the most inclusive and forward-thinking employee offerings, ranging from housing assistance to family and college planning, along with strategies that companies can implement to ensure that well-being resources are accessible.Well-Being Starts at the TopNo matter your area of business, says Kenneth Reeves, VP, HR, Performance Food Group, “well-being starts at the top. You can have all the programs in the world, but if you aren’t walking the talk and doing things with your people, then it’s all a check-the-box exercise.” Leaders at the company hold monthly meetings with their front-line workers, the delivery drivers, to see how they are doing and thank them for their work, says Reeves. “Those are some of the things that we do to make sure that we stay connected with the heart and the soul of what we do on a daily basis,” he said.For Liane Hajduch, head of employee experience & HR tech at DoorDash, engagement surveys are just the start of employee listening and engagement. “We work really closely with leaders to deeply understand what people are saying, to take swift action, to empower people to take it, to ensure folks know it’s a safe space, and [that] we’re actually going to do something about it,” Hajduch said. DoorDash’s quarterly surveys have a high participation rate of nearly 90%, partly due to the fact that workers trust that leaders will act on the results.Communicating Benefits OpportunitiesCreatively and effectively marketing benefits to employees helps them feel engaged, appreciated, and hopefully, loyal. Insight gained from employee listening can even be used in the marketing itself. Stephanie Murphy, PhD, VP of people experience, UnitedHealth Group, shares that her organization offers a “one pass” that gives access to gyms and local fitness classes. “We found out through just having conversations that [one employee] had done the one pass and lost 150 pounds. This is a story. This is something that impacts people’s lives,” Murphy said. The employee shared his story several times across various channels, and more people started participating in the program. “Using storytelling to really get the benefits out there resonates more than just sending an email saying, ‘Here’s your list of benefits that we offer,’” Murphy said.Executive panelists spoke to the topic "Supporting Equity Through Workplace Well-Being"“We are totally inundated with information overload,” said moderator Kelsey Bradshaw, newsletter editor at City Cast Austin, so how can your marketing break through? Use every method you can, says Murphy: emails, social media, break room posters, presentations, and having the CEO share it in all-hands meetings.Reeves’ organization offers an annual total rewards statement, so employees fully understand and appreciate the impact of their benefits program. “People understand, ‘Wow, yes, I took X home, but this is everything that the organization is putting into my financial well-being on my behalf,’” he said. Murphy says ultimately, the onus is on managers to make sure they are also communicating benefits as they are the ones with direct and routine access to their people.Investing in Employees“One of the biggest issues among American workers is that they're living paycheck-to-paycheck,” Bradshaw said, which has a significant impact on employees’ mental health and performance. “Employees typically spend three plus hours per week worrying about their finances,” Talbot-Kelly said. She says this manifests in three ways: reduced productivity, higher absenteeism, and increased turnover. “Financial stress ultimately impacts the bottom line.”Post-pandemic inflation means that offering just 401(k) is no longer enough. “Financial wellness is ensuring that your employees can meet both their short and long-term goals,” Talbot-Kelly said. In addition to retirement options, employers should consider offering on-demand pay to help employees pay bills on time and avoid overdrafts.And financial planning for rent and mortgages is also helping, since housing is one of employees’ largest recurring costs. “If you can bring that down 15-20%, then ultimately your employees will have better mental health and more disposable income to spend on other things, be that childcare or food,” said Jerryck Murrey, CEO, Annum. His organization offers housing benefits that allow employees to save money for rent, mortgages, contractors, appliances, and furniture. “Housing is the fulcrum of life–you remove housing, everything falls apart,” he said. Especially, Murrey says, with so many employees now working from home.Staying on Top of TrendsCompanies should keep a pulse on housing prices and ensure that their compensation and benefits are keeping pace with local economics and competitors. Our world is changing faster than ever, and your organization should be keeping up, staying “nimble and adaptable, being comfortable with the fact that what you did last year isn’t going to be what you’re going to do the next year,” Hajduch said.DoorDash offers a flexible benefits program that includes a wellness credit to spend on whatever makes the most sense to the employee, be that childcare, housing, medical care, or the like. Such flexibility is vital in an increasingly diverse workforce. “The workforce today is composed of different generations with little shared experiences,” Murrey said, and employers need to be able to provide benefits for all life stages and styles.Hajduch says DoorDash offers a coaching platform featuring coaches with a wide variety of expertise, from career coaches, to financial wellness gurus, to mental health counselors. When selecting benefits options, always remember the defining features of the younger generations, say Reeves and Murrey: they want personal development and they want meaning in their work.Hajduch offers words of wisdom for organizations looking to revamp their well-being offerings: “You have to be cognizant not to overdo it in the early days, because it’s very hard to take things back as you scale and grow, and maybe cannot afford them. So be really thoughtful about what you can spend, what the future could look like, and how this would scale over time.”Katie Chambers is a freelance writer and award-winning communications executive with a lifelong commitment to supporting artists and advocating for inclusion. Her work has been seen in HuffPost and several printed essay collections, among others, and she has appeared on Cheddar News, iWomanTV, On New Jersey, and CBS New York.

Katie Chambers | December 10, 2024