How Behavioral Science and ‘Nudge Theory’ Can Make a Difference in Gender Equality

BY Jenic Mantashian | November 05, 2019

Since humans are creatures of habit and tradition, they’ll tend to keep doing what they’re doing until something motivates them to change. Individuals may change their behavior for reasons particular to them, but what if leaders in business or government want to solve problems by encouraging change across a whole group of people? The thriving field of behavioral science has produced a wealth of insights in how to “nudge” people with gentle pushes that can add up to a big impact. Behavioral-science firm the BVA Nudge Unit is a global consultancy that helps clients ranging from Air France to the World Wildlife Fund to create sustainable change, both inside and outside their organizations. In an interview with From Day One, we asked Jenic Mantashian, Executive Vice President of the BVA Nudge Unit USA, about her company’s work in the field. Excerpts:

From Day One: Your organization recently helped the U.N. to engage 1 billion men in the cause of gender equality using behavioral science. That's a lot of people to sway. To start with, can you tell us about behavioral science as a field and give us some examples of its insights and tools?

Mantashian: Behavioral science is a field of study that brings together several disciplines, among them cognitive science, social psychology and behavioral economics.  In very simple terms, behavioral science seeks to understand the true drivers of human behavior.

As a consulting practice it’s a relatively new field, but has really taken off.  There have been several Nobel Prizes awarded to people for their work in behavioral science, as more and more people see its value for solving problems. Specifically, as a practice, it uncovers the cognitive biases, emotional and social influences, and the impact of context on our behavior. With those insights, we can pursue informed strategies to resolve what are otherwise intractable problems.

Some of the most well-known areas where applied behavioral science has emerged as a practice was in consumer finance and global health. Specifically, through the application of nudges, individuals were successfully encouraged to save more money for retirement and to vaccinate their children, respectively.

How do you define "nudge," as you deploy it among a particular group?

I should mention that the term “nudge” was coined by two leaders in this field, Richard Thaler and Cass Sunstein.   In fact, they wrote the book on it–Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth, and Happiness.

The way I explain a nudge to people is that it is a small discrete intervention that is inspired by insights uncovered through our understanding of human behavior. It guides beneficial behaviors in such a way whereby choice is not limited, so people don’t feel forced.  Nudges can be carried out through changes to a physical space, by communicating in an intentional way, or simply by including behavioral strategies within any interaction with a group or individual.  For example, you can nudge employee behaviors in a meeting simply by being very deliberate about the name of the meeting room or the title of your meeting–in effect, priming the participants.

Jenic Mantashian is Executive Vice President of the BVA Nudge Unit USA

What is HeForShe, the movement you supported for the U.S., and what are some of the behaviors it seeks to address?

HeForShe is a solidarity campaign initiated by the U.N. for the global advancement of gender equality.  The movement invites men specifically, and people of all gender identifications, to stand in solidarity with women to create a brave, visible, and united force for gender equality.

From a behavioral perspective, as a first step, HeForShe “pre-engages” with men by gaining their commitment. They’re persuaded to sign up to be part of the movement on HeForShe.org. As a second step, HeForShe encourages those registered to take action in favor of gender equality within their own communities.

Naturally the specific behaviors are quite broad and varied, since each country and context is so different. The subjects of the nudges could range from heads of state, who have the ability to change laws related to pay equality, all the way to university students, who have the ability to foster a campus environment where women are safe from sexual assault.

Why is there a need to deploy behavioral science to influence these ingrained behaviors, rather than more traditional methods like public-service advertising?

I would start off by saying that giving people information is essential. Information helps establish an intent. Without an intent to act a certain way, it’s hard to make it happen.

With that said, time and again we have seen that information is simply not enough to change behavior. For example, we know that eating sugar and processed foods on a regular basis can lead to diabetes. We know that smoking cigarettes can lead to cancer.  We know that driving and texting can lead to fatal accidents. There is so much information out there on these topics, but millions of people still engage in these deadly behaviors.

What behavioral science and nudges allow us to do is complement the information we receive, so we can take a more comprehensive approach. For example, next time I have a craving for sweets, if I made changes to my kitchen environment that nudged me away from the cookies and nudged me towards the fruit, it will support me better with my intent to eat healthier.

Can you explain the use of commitment as a step toward change, and why it proves effective?’

We know from many experiments in our field that when someone commits to a future behavior, they are more likely to do it. For example, in one experiment, hotel guests were asked for a pre-commitment to reuse towels to support eco-friendly behavior at the hotel, and by simply having people check a box, there was a 25% average increase in the reuse of towels. It is believed by some that engaging in the commitment dissolves any cognitive dissonance that results from not following through on the committed action. And since humans look for ways to avoid discomfort, we are more likely to follow through with the action to avoid the guilt or conflict that can arise.

In a recent article, you identified many "drivers of influence." Could you offer a couple of prime examples?

Sure. At the BVA Nudge Unit, we created a tool that we coined the 21 Drivers of Influence.  The tool isolates 21 of the most powerful heuristic-based levers, from more than 200 that have been identified in the field, that can be used to amplify the effectiveness of specific activations. In other words, they serve as behavioral science-based inspirations that drive our ideation process when we design strategies and nudges to change behavior.

Commitment is one of those drivers. Another popular one is “Social Norms,” where we exploit the insight that people want to feel a sense of belonging and thus will be more likely to act in a way that’s like the rest of the group. If you look at Amazon, they use this driver very well, by showing you the popularity of a product, along with its ratings and endorsements by others. Another one is “Easiness,” which is the understanding that we are more likely to do something if it’s undemanding. That’s what Amazon was thinking in designing their “one click” check-out option.

You also talk about "stairs of change." Could you describe the process?

At the BVA Nudge Unit we have a proprietary behavioral framework that’s a step-wise process that inspires the development of behavioral science strategies and nudges. The best way to think about our Stairs of Change is to imagine you are climbing up four stories of a building, where each of the four stories represents an important stage. As you ascend to the top, you get closer to achieving your end goal.  However, if any of the steps are skipped haphazardly, you risk the collapse of your effort.

In other words, we break down the steps to the behavior into four areas and work on each of them. At the step “Preparing the Field,” we think about how to awaken the attention of our target, such as finding the right time, place and messenger. We take this through to “Reinforce the Behavior,” where we think about things like providing reassurance through feedback, recognizing the behavior through rewards, and activating social diffusion.

What kinds of results are you seeing from such programs, for example your work with the HeForShe movement?

The results have been very positive. Our primary focus with the U.N. was to nudge the commitment process, getting men to commit to the movement. Shortly after our interventions were launched, using analytics from HeForShe.org, it was determined that commitments jumped from 2% to 25% conversions among website visitors.

We’re also now working with HeForShe Champion corporations on the application of nudge within their organizations. Among other steps, they’re optimizing recruitment and hiring practices through the use of our frameworks in order to ensure gender-balanced workforces in specific sectors, along with achieving a more diverse workforce overall. We are in the testing phase and hope to share the good results soon.

What are some other examples from behavioral science in fostering diversity and gender equality, particularly in the corporate sector?

There are a lot of published examples out there and a good resource to access many of them can be found in our book called Nudge Management. Nudges can be put in place to encourage D&I at all stages of the employee experience. Let me give you some examples:

When hiring: In advertisements, only list requirements that are key to the position. Research has shown that there are trends in the way specific groups respond to job advertisements. For instance, women tend to apply only when they feel they meet 100% of the required capabilities on a job advertisement, while men are likely to apply when they meet only 60%of those qualifications.

To debias annual reviews: At a mid-size U.S. tech company, the annual-review process involved managers discussing staff performance. Comments were largely about employees’ personalities rather than their actual work, and included various stereotypes. A study showed that 14% women were criticized for being too aggressive, 8% of men were criticized for being “too soft.”  The company initiated an employee scorecard which focused on the work output and its impact on the business and not the individual. The result? A year after rolling out new scorecard, none of the women were criticized for being too aggressive, and less than 1% of men were criticized for being “too soft.”

To increase diversity in global job assignments: An international assignment is often seen as a crucial step in a successful career in large organizations. But not many women declare themselves open to international mobility. In a global company, simply rephrasing the question on an employee-development questionnaire–from “are you internationally mobile?” to “would you consider an international assignment sometime in the future?”—led to a 25% increase the number of women declaring they were mobile, and thus candidates for further management development.

That said, it’s important to note that these methods don’t necessarily work in every situation. Contexts change how people behave. That’s why ad-hoc solutions are generally recommended.

Looking ahead, what other problems are you aiming to address by wielding behavioral science?

Basically, any problems that exist where there are humans involved, we want to be there to support positive change. On the Nudge Management side, when nudging within organizations, this can range from encouraging entrepreneurial behavior among sales reps and the adoption of new sales automation platforms, to promoting compliance with safety rules and regulations, to adopting behavior that supports communication or innovation.    More broadly, we also are working on using behavioral science to improve customer experience, to adopt sustainable behavior, and promote the quality of life and standard of living in cities.

Editor’s Note: BVA Nudge Unit USA is a sponsor of From Day One. The author of this article can be reached at jenic.mantashian@bvanudgeunit.com  


RELATED STORIES

AI-Powered, Human-Centered Team Transformation at Scale

Work norms have shifted rapidly over the past four years. With hybrid work becoming the norm, organizations now face the challenge of engaging all team members while staying aligned with company goals.At From Day One’s Boston conference, AceUp’s founder and CEO, Will Foussier and chief technology officer, Rohit Begani, spoke in a thought leadership spotlight about “AI-Powered, Human-Centered Team Transformation At Scale.” Amid shifts in work locations, schedules, and efficiencies, some organizations lag in adopting AI—yet it can streamline operations and support flexible teams.Foussier cited a “connection crisis” affecting hybrid and dispersed teams. Nearly 80% of  employees work on a hybrid model, emphasizing the need to develop strategies for better  team engagement and collaboration, says Foussier. Among those 80%, only 23% expressed  feeling connected to the company. To address this, AceUp focuses on team coaching,  leveraging AI to drive business impact and connect teams to specific OKRs and KPIs.Begani, left, and Foussier, right, spoke during the thought leadership spotlightCompanies who utilize team coaching benefit from upskilling and reskilling opportunities and  can easily implement virtual team members into the happenings of the company. It is designed  to tailor the coaching to the needs and goals of the business. “The beauty of team coaching is that you can actually bring people together to address a business challenge,” said Foussier. AceUp created a way to effectively utilize AI to enhance current coaching sessions for  businesses rather than replace them altogether. They achieve this by focusing on AI-driven team-building methods that reshape how leaders and employees work together. “We have seen that it helps them clearly define a goal which is aligned with their business goal, and help them track the outcomes of team coaching,” Begani said.Using AceUp’s AI bot Ally, coaching sessions can now help companies detect and analyze  where improvement is needed. Ally joins the call as a normal coaching participant, captures  video, audio, and analyzes that data to discover breakthrough moments.  “With all of this data, we are able to provide hyper-personalized coaching–and this coaching  is for moments that matter,” Begani said. “These individuals are already going through coaching with a human coach, but because we have an understanding of their gaps, there's an  ability for a model to support them on specific needs.” Once the data from the team coaching sessions are collected, it is managed in a dashboard  that breaks down the information and reports any discrepancies. Then, the company can  assess and redirect to decide how to change them.  The future of leadership lies in teams. This idea inspired a team-coaching model that uses AI to collect session data, enabling personalized experiences, tailored goal setting, knowledge retention, and deeper insights into company dynamics. AceUp’s approach shifts from “me” to “we,” from leadership to team-ship, and from manager-as-coach to team-as-coach.Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, AceUp, for sponsoring this thought leadership spotlight. Mary Jones is a freelance writer out of Ohio. Her work is featured in several publications including The Dallas Express, NDash, and The Daily Advocate.

Mary Jones | November 01, 2024

Using Education Benefits to Attract and Retain a Uniquely-Skilled Workforce

Collectively, Americans carry about $1.7 trillion in student debt, second only to home loan debt. “So even if you are one of the lucky ones who doesn’t have any student debt attached to your name, you probably know someone who does, and you have probably not been able to escape the chatter around just student debt today,” said Michaela Rubin, VP of operations at financial wellness platform Candidly, during a From Day One webinar on tuition reimbursement and student loan benefits.Because of the size of loans and the damage such debt can do over time, education assistance is becoming a popular benefit category among employers, says Rubin. “There are a lot of legislative tailwinds, like the CARES Act of 2020 and Secure Act 2.0, that are also feeding into this conversation. While we started primarily as a student debt repayment platform, we’ve seen the importance of combining these newer benefits with traditional benefits like tuition reimbursement. Employers need to set themselves apart and stand out, and this becomes a really big differentiator, especially when there are a lot of eyes on this right now.”It’s certainly a differentiator for the Hazelden Betty Ford Foundation, says Heather Galvin, the organization’s compensation and benefits analyst, who joined Rubin for the webinar. “Not only is pursuing higher education financially burdensome for the workforce, it can affect mental health too. An offering like this just goes to show employees and workforce members that you’re invested in their whole health and their whole well-being.” The non-profit, headquartered in Center City, Minnesota, operates centers for drug and alcohol treatment as well as mental healthcare.Though tuition reimbursement is more common than employer contributions to student debt, “participation in tuition reimbursement programs is historically pretty low,” said Rubin. The majority of workers say they want some kind of upskilling or training, but only a small fraction participate, often because they’re not aware it’s available.Tuition reimbursement requires the employee to put up the money for the training or education, complete the program, and then file for reimbursement from the company. For student loan repayment, the company contributes to paying off an employee’s pre-existing student debt. Both have their tax boons for employees and employers.Journalist Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza moderated the discussion about "Tuition Reimbursement and Student Loan Benefits: A Smarter Way to Attract, Retain, and Engage" (photo by From Day One)Galvin said the decision to offer tuition reimbursement was an easy one. They want and need uniquely educated employees, and they offer a graduate program of their own, the Hazelden Betty Ford Graduate school, where students can earn master’s degrees in addiction and mental health counseling. “It’s one of our strongest recruitment pipelines,” she said. “Aside from career advancement and professional growth opportunities for our workforce, we saw this as a great opportunity to increase loyalty and job satisfaction. We know we’re creating a more motivated and engaged workforce. We feel that by investing in our workforce and their future, we are simultaneously investing in our own.”Running a Successful Student Loan Benefit ProgramWith her clients, Rubin discusses goals, budget, and workforce makeup. The latter is particularly important for employers that require their workers to have secondary or postsecondary degrees to qualify for the job. Those employees likely enter with considerable debt and would benefit from loan repayment benefits. Other employers may be heavily focused on upskilling the workforce they already have and would be wise to explore tuition reimbursement. Some will need both.Any student loan program requires a carefully prepared communication campaign that builds awareness and clearly outlines expectations. Rejecting reimbursement requests because the student disqualifies on a technicality or mistakenly promotes benefits to ineligible workers, will significantly damage the reputation of the program.At the Hazelden Betty Ford Foundation, Galvin folds the organization’s education assistance program into its benefits guide and stores it on the intranet. She also likes to promote it in sync with the school calendar when people are typically thinking about their education. Rubin said she likes to promote quick-start user guides and quarterly toolkits. But don’t wait for employees to arrive to advertise your program, they said, make it a part of your recruitment strategy. Tout it on your careers page and in your job postings.Galvin said the program has been remarkably successful for her organization. Those who have registered and activated their tuition reimbursement have stayed. “This has potentially retained 23 workforce members who may have otherwise left. Said another way, it’s potentially saved us over a million dollars in turnover costs.” Currently, there are 167 graduates from the Hazelden Betty Ford graduate school working at the foundation. “Those are employees who, more than likely, participated in tuition reimbursement and/or are now eligible for student loan repayment.” This, she says demonstrates the organization’s appreciation for those who both further their education and stick with the organization. Plus, it works.Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, Candidly, for sponsoring this webinar.Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza is a freelance journalist and From Day One contributing editor who writes about work, the job market, and women’s experiences in the workplace. Her work has appeared in the Economist, the BBC, The Washington Post, Quartz, Business Insider, Fast Company, and Digiday’s Worklife.

Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza | November 01, 2024

Learning to Lead From the Inside Out, a Step-by-Step Approach to Transforming Leaders

Hans-Werner Kaas, co-author of The Journey of Leadership, believes today’s leaders must become more vulnerable, self-aware, and humanist. Kaas has helped guide more than 500 CEOs internationally to achieve authentic self-development and actualize their professional goals of running successful organizations as the co-dean of McKinsey & Company’s CEO leadership program “The Bower Forum.”The Inside Out methodology used in the program equally upholds personal and professional integrity. This methodology upholds self-awareness as evolved and palpable leadership resulting in a more engaging and ethical company culture and sustainable organizational success.In a thought leadership spotlight at From Day One’s September virtual conference, Kaas emphasized that adapting to today’s climate calls for collaborative and human-centered strategies.Our society has evolved past the outdated notions that one person, the tunnel-visioned “imperial CEO,” has all the answers or will be the smartest in the room, Kaas says. Accordingly, it’s essential to align with evolving needs where personal transparency, integrity, and values drive effective leadership, foster meaningful connections both within and beyond the workplace, and create a greater impact in inspiring others.More meaningful goals and solutions are created with honest dialogue. People connect more deeply with a leader who openly shares their journey toward personal and professional fulfillment.Kaas cited the importance of self-assessments, such as CEOs reflecting on their respective sense of belonging to determine if they create that sense of belonging for people around them. “How do you show up?” Kaas asked.Leading From the Inside OutThe Bower Forum involves 3-5 CEOs seeking guidance from mentors such as Kaas, co-author and colleague Ramesh Srinivasan, and other former CEOs. It consists of a two-fold program combining internal and external sources and factors.First, the attendees are asked to describe their personal and organizational progress. Before arriving at the forum, they are also encouraged to bring feedback from their executive teams, mentors, family, or friends on their emotional outlook, self-awareness, empathy, vulnerability, and humility.After attendees share their current stage in their leadership journey, they participate in a listening and immersion exercise. During this exercise, they listen to their peers’ stories, exploring the experiences and motivations that may have shaped specific behaviors or thought patterns in each individual. Their peers brainstorm solutions to those existing behavioral and thought patterns that may prevent them from achieving the kind of leadership they aspire to.Hans-Werner Kaas, the co-dean of the CEO leadership program “The Bower Forum,” spoke during the thought leadership spotlight (company photo)Next, Kaas helps develop ways for the attendee to self-actualize their vision of becoming the leader they want to be for their executive team and organization. The emphasis is on the humanistic aspect of achieving their vision: “Because leadership change starts with yourself,” Kaas said.Attendees proceed to create a commitment plan: a roadmap of how they can effectively take charge of their personal lives and then show up for their teams and organizations with the same commitment to authenticity, well-being, and their vision of success.The Bower Forum incorporates several elements of the self-assessments found within the book “The Journey of Leadership.” For example, at the end of every chapter in the book, there are questions for self-reflection where readers can pinpoint their current position in life, where they want to go, and who they want to be.The book also contains examples of renowned industry pioneers incorporating more vulnerable leadership. Mark Fields, former CEO of the Ford Motor Company, initially experienced dissent in Japan and sought a listening and immersion session from his peers and mentors to gain more perspective of Japanese culture and empathy and understanding of the executive team questioning his leadership.The Bower Forum has run more than 145 programs over 12 years with CEOs in business and non-business sectors, gaining unique insight and comprehensive leadership guidance contributing to the success of “The Journey to Leadership,” says Kaas.What sets the program and book apart from other leadership coaching is the strong focus on human-centered leadership. This marks a monumental shift from the traditional, authoritative CEO model to one centered on empathy and connection. “No surprise, the change, and the transformation always starts with ourselves. But it’s also the hardest thing to take a step back.”Editor's note: From Day One thanks our partner, McKinsey & Company, for sponsoring this thought leadership spotlight. Stephanie Reed is a freelance news, marketing, and content writer. Much of her work features small business owners throughout diverse industries. She is passionate about promoting small, ethical, and eco-conscious businesses.

Stephanie Reed | October 30, 2024