The Future of Talent Acquisition: Perfecting the Human Experience in the Age of AI

BY Matthew Koehler | January 09, 2024

Gen Z will make up the majority of the workforce by 2030, and they’re a bit of an oddity in the hiring process. They want their transition from college to career to contain a bit of the old, like internships, work experience, and completed classes but especially the new, like quick and easy online applications. 

“What we’re seeing is that the ease of modern applications and technology is really contributing to this high volume of applications,” said Kate Beckman, executive manager of RippleMatch. “Students today are taking advantage of the way that technology is designed for volume without necessarily taking into account what happens after that application is submitted.”

RippleMatch is a job matching AI technology and the brainchild of Andrew Myers, founder and CEO, who experienced his own turbulent entry into the job market after college. Beckman and Myers joined freelance journalist, and former managing editor of CNN Business, Kelly Bourdet, for a From Day One webinar. The platform started in Myers’ dorm and was “created to make life easy on companies so they can provide really strong candidate experiences and access the right candidates, regardless of race, background, or where the candidates come from.”

Eliminating Bias and Streamlining the Hiring Process

“We’ve been conducting a lot of research on Gen Z through the years, but new data really shows that the next generation of candidates are influencing the recruitment process for everyone,” Beckman said. She provided some key insights and research to head the conversation on how AI can perfect the human experience in talent acquisition.

According to Beckman’s research for RippleMatch:

  • 50% of students said they'll submit over 100 applications (just this past autumn), a third of those will submit closer to 200.
  • More than two thirds believe companies should respond to them within 5-7 days.
  • 72% of candidates say they would feel frustrated if they took the time to file an application and never heard anything back. They’d prefer an impersonal rejection notification over nothing at all. 
  • Gen Z job seekers expect no more than four weeks to get a response on a job, even if it's a rejection. 
  • About 70% say if they’ve gone through some kind of interview process that not hearing back lends to a negative experience.
  • Lack of information on what to expect going forward is another contributing factor to a negative application process.
  • A lack of diversity amongst interviewers is another factor that weighs on the minds of job seekers. 
  • Black and Hispanic women select that lack of diversity among interviewers is the number two factor that will contribute to a negative experience interviewing. 

The biggest hurdle for AI in talent acquisition is not reproducing the bias of their human creators as early platforms did. Myers says the goal and success of modern AI is to fix the mistakes of the past.

Previously, recruiters would focus on the same top schools for candidates, which exacerbated biases. The same was, and still is, done in corporate America with diversity recruiting. Recruiters end up at the same HBCUs or HSIs, but neglect other talent pools.

“There are incredible HBCUs and HSIs all over the country. But if we’re speaking from a representation perspective for Black or Latine candidates, many of those candidates don’t go to HBCUs or HSIs," Myers said.

But as other From Day One panel experts have discussed, without proper monitoring, AI will reinforce human biases. To better train bias out of the AI recruitment process, Myers says you have to focus on outcomes, not intentions.

Moderator Kelly Bourdet spoke with Andrew Myers and Kate Beckman of RippleMatch at the From Day One webinar (photo by From Day One)

“This is a really new space. And even the regulators are having to learn how to do this really thoughtfully on the fly,” Myers said. The technology is there. “There just hasn’t been a very AI-focused diversity company that’s really existed on a massive scale before.”

One of the regulators Myers referenced is a New York law seeking to regulate how companies use AI in the hiring process. The law requires employers to have annual third-party 'bias audits' to show that the AI technology they use is free of racist or sexist bias, according to reporting from Axios.

However, as Beckman points out, modern AI tools are helping companies move beyond academic prestige, “which inhibits representation and diversity” by pushing them to “expand their reach and sort through those candidates in a more efficient manner.”

Efficiency, though, has created an arms race of submitting applications where neither the candidate nor the employer wins. To avoid this, RippleMatch sends job seekers opportunities that truly fit their skills and qualifications. They quickly send a rejection if they’re not a fit for the role, or help companies move forward quickly if they are, Beckman says.

“The beauty of AI is you can instantly tell that probably 50-75% of candidates don’t meet a basic qualification for a role,” Myers said. “We sometimes picture AI being this black box, doing all these weird scores. But the reality is, AI can be really transparent as to why a candidate isn’t qualified.”

To accurately and efficiently match candidates, RippleMatch does two things. On the company side, they figure out what’s missing from their talent pipeline. On the candidate side, instead of getting “all these messages that feel a lot like spam,”  Myers says they’re getting sent opportunities directly related to their skills. “If you’re getting this opportunity, it means you’re really qualified. The company’s missing a candidate like you, and you should certainly pay attention to the opportunity.”

Beckman says that with Gen Z, a cohort that’s just entering the workforce and may not have a lot of experience, RippleMatch can point them in the right direction, or towards jobs they didn’t know existed. “If you’re at a career fair, you go to the most recognizable companies. So many companies out there offer amazing pay and awesome culture, and candidates just aren’t discovering them organically. But this technology automates that career discovery process."

Applying for Jobs and Starting a New One

What are the challenges RippleMatch sees going forward? Balance and nobility.

Beckman points to the convenience AI lends to the application process, especially for Gen Z, but says a balance must be struck between using the technology to enhance career discovery and starting a job, not just endlessly applying for hundreds of jobs.

“Submitting 200 applications because you just have to click a button instead of considering, is this an organization I want to work for? Am I invested in what this company is doing? Am I excited about this job description?” Myers said.

Myers sees a noble cause in connecting people to the right jobs but touched on the apprehension and risk in AI. “I think being in the TA space, especially early career, is incredibly noble. Connecting people with the right jobs is a really meaningful thing to do. Jobs have such an impact on people’s identities, their livelihood, and on their families.”

“My biggest push on AI in general is, if this is something that you’re passionate about, don't avoid it because you have some concerns. Engage in how we can design the course of this technology in a way that’s actually really good for humanity and for the values that you care about," Myers said.

Editor's note: From Day One thanks our partner, RippleMatch, for sponsoring this webinar. 

Matthew Koehler is a freelance journalist and licensed real estate agent based in Washington, DC. His work has appeared in Greater Greater Washington, The Washington Post, The Southwester, and Walking Cinema, among others.


RELATED STORIES

Leveraging Generational Diversity: Moving from Ageism to Age Inclusion

In a recent survey from Resume Now, 90% of workers age 40+ said they experienced ageism in the workplace. And a study from AARP found that 64% of the same age group experienced age discrimination, meaning tangible impact on one’s ability to advance, stay in the workforce, and get paid fairly. “The data shows that ageism is still with us, unfortunately, in the workforce, and that it’s actually quite prevalent,” said Heather Tinsley-Fix, senior advisor, financial resilience, AARP, at a From Day One webinar.The five-generation workforce is a well-known phenomenon—in fact, 83% of executives believe that creating a more multigenerational workforce would drive their organization’s success and growth. But how should companies begin to build cultures that shift away from unconscious ageism toward age inclusion?Dr. Megan Gerhardt, founder & director of thought leadership at Gentelligence, has spent the last 15 years speaking and consulting with top organizations worldwide on leveraging generational diversity in the workplace. Gerhardt spoke with Tinsley-Fix and Heather Ainsworth, CEO of Workable Concept, on creating cultures in which all ages thrive, psychological safety enables fruitful interaction, and intergenerational collaboration drives bottom-line value. They also shared a sneak peek of a new suite of resources AARP designed specifically to help HR leaders address this opportunity. It translates research into specific actions and creates custom plans that takes into account your own areas of personal power and influence.Turning From Ageism to Age InclusionThe World Health Organization defines ageism as “the stereotypes (how we think), prejudice (how we feel), and discrimination (how we act) toward others or oneself based on age.” The workplace can be rife with generational stereotypes, with headlines constantly decrying both Gen Z and Millennials as “the worst colleagues” (and also sometimes, puzzlingly, “the best”), while also insisting that Baby Boomers retire to free up jobs for those younger folks. And while many, Tinsley-Fix says, wrongly peg those 45-55 at “late career” and 55-65 in “decline,” in fact, “people 65 plus are the fastest growing segment of the workforce.”Conversely, age inclusion is “when a team or organization creates policies, tools, and culture that enable people of all ages to thrive without needing to navigate age-based stereotypes, prejudice, or discrimination.”An effective leadership team will build a complex, inclusive culture where workers of all ages and stages can thrive. It’s not only a kind choice, it’s what Tinsley-Fix calls “a value creation strategy hiding in plain sight.” The depth of experience and skill sets in an age-diverse workforce, whether technical, professional, or durable human skills, creates major opportunities for employers who can unleash those synergies. The best results occur when people from different life and career stages work together to define problems and create solutions. Having workers of different ages allows you to connect with a wider customer base and gives you a more nuanced knowledge base to call on.“Having workers of different ages is also a talent management necessity,” Tinsley-Fix said. In the near-term, workers 65+ are the fastest-growing portion of the talent market, but over the coming decades, more people will exit the workforce than will enter it. AARP posits that “declining population or labor force participation rates among younger workers may lead to talent shortage. Retaining older workers (considered age 40+) can help employers address this challenge.”Learning to Work TogetherContrary to popular belief, the five generations in the workforce work well together. “Data shows that multi-generational teams perform better when they’re managed well than teams which are more age-siloed. In companies that utilize mixed age work teams, the productivity of both older workers and the younger workers is higher than in companies that do not use mixed age teams,” Tinsley-Fix said. “That myth that productivity declines as we age is based on measuring individual productivity rather than team productivity. Mixed age teams outperform teams on things like decision-making, creative tasks, and complex problem solving.”With this in mind, it’s important for leaders to encourage generativity, which is defined as “a person’s interest in and dedication to establishing and guiding the next generation.” Gerhardt encourages cultivating “gentelligence,” the idea of helping people have smarter intergenerational conversations. This shows up at work through co-creation, providing expertise freely, setting up organizations for success, consulting, coaching, and mentoring.The panelist spoke about "Leveraging Generational Diversity: Moving from Ageism to Age Inclusion" during the webinar (photo by From Day One)“This can also show up just in how people approach conversations,” said Ainsworth. “Is a conversation between people of different generations seen as transactional, or do they approach it with a sense of curiosity in order to co-create value and the culture that they want to be working in?”Creating an Organization That Supports Generativity“An age-diverse workforce left to its own devices is not necessarily going to be more productive,” Gerhardt said. “It has the potential to be, but like almost all forms of diversity, that rests solely on how well it's managed and led. And that includes the cultures and climates we're creating.”It’s important to encourage intergenerational interaction since it may not occur naturally, Gerhardt says, as employees often work their way up through the ranks alongside colleagues similar in age who become their friends. This lack of relationship-building can lead to age polarization. And without regular proactive exposure to other generations, stereotypes can flourish. Encourage employees to “see the value that every generation brings,” Gerhardt says, and build out a benefits package that offers perks specific to every stage of life, from student loan repayment to childcare, elder care, retirement, and more. And determine the level of psychological safety for each age group and career stage, noting that low levels of safety can result in disinterest or even concern about sharing knowledge.Much of this comes down to helping different generations understand each other better in order to strengthen trust and collaborate effectively. “I think it’s a myth that our younger generations aren’t interested in listening or learning from people who are older. I think it’s that how they want to communicate, learn, and listen has changed,” Gerhardt said. One example she shares is that Gen Z grew up having all the answers at their fingertips, so if they don’t immediately receive the “why” behind  something—like why it might take 18 months to get promoted—it can impact their psychological safety. That doesn’t mean a workplace needs to cater exclusively to the young, but it should be extra mindful to have inclusive communications that account for all learning and work styles.Gerhardt suggests proactively creating opportunities for those significantly older and younger to collaborate on meaningful work where diverse expertise is needed for success. “Generativity comes from being curious,” Gerhardt said. Smarter intergenerational conversations can be sparked by “Gentelligent” power questions like: “How would you approach this? Can you help me understand that perspective? What barriers can I help remove for you to reach this goal?”Generations at WorkAn age-inclusive organization should:Welcome workers of all ages and value their experienceLive by the mantra that everyone has something to teach and everyone has something to learnBe flexible, recognizing that longer lives mean loopier career pathsSupport caregivers with leave, resources, and other benefitsManage differences and celebrate similarities across multiple generationsNot put people in buckets or make assumptions about them based on ageAARP just launched Generations at Work, a new tool packed with resources to help you take action to build and leverage a multigenerational workforce. It guides you through a self-assessment to help you create a customized plan based on your existing strategies and future priorities; provides free resources to help you executive each of three key actions; and ensures you distill your learnings and bring them back to the team.AARP believes setting a handful of targeted goals to improve age inclusion makes us more likely to achieve the changes we seek. Leveraging a multigenerational workforce requires us to consider actions across HR, both with teams and individual employees. Learn more and create your customized plan at https://employerportal.aarp.org/generations.Editor's note: From Day One thanks our partner, AARP, for sponsoring this webinar.Katie Chambers is a freelance writer and award-winning communications executive with a lifelong commitment to supporting artists and advocating for inclusion. Her work has been seen in HuffPost and several printed essay collections, among others, and she has appeared on Cheddar News, iWomanTV, On New Jersey, and CBS New York.

Katie Chambers | November 04, 2024

Using Education Benefits to Attract and Retain a Uniquely-Skilled Workforce

Collectively, Americans carry about $1.7 trillion in student debt, second only to home loan debt. “So even if you are one of the lucky ones who doesn’t have any student debt attached to your name, you probably know someone who does, and you have probably not been able to escape the chatter around just student debt today,” said Michaela Rubin, VP of operations at financial wellness platform Candidly, during a From Day One webinar on tuition reimbursement and student loan benefits.Because of the size of loans and the damage such debt can do over time, education assistance is becoming a popular benefit category among employers, says Rubin. “There are a lot of legislative tailwinds, like the CARES Act of 2020 and Secure Act 2.0, that are also feeding into this conversation. While we started primarily as a student debt repayment platform, we’ve seen the importance of combining these newer benefits with traditional benefits like tuition reimbursement. Employers need to set themselves apart and stand out, and this becomes a really big differentiator, especially when there are a lot of eyes on this right now.”It’s certainly a differentiator for the Hazelden Betty Ford Foundation, says Heather Galvin, the organization’s compensation and benefits analyst, who joined Rubin for the webinar. “Not only is pursuing higher education financially burdensome for the workforce, it can affect mental health too. An offering like this just goes to show employees and workforce members that you’re invested in their whole health and their whole well-being.” The non-profit, headquartered in Center City, Minnesota, operates centers for drug and alcohol treatment as well as mental healthcare.Though tuition reimbursement is more common than employer contributions to student debt, “participation in tuition reimbursement programs is historically pretty low,” said Rubin. The majority of workers say they want some kind of upskilling or training, but only a small fraction participate, often because they’re not aware it’s available.Tuition reimbursement requires the employee to put up the money for the training or education, complete the program, and then file for reimbursement from the company. For student loan repayment, the company contributes to paying off an employee’s pre-existing student debt. Both have their tax boons for employees and employers.Journalist Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza moderated the discussion about "Tuition Reimbursement and Student Loan Benefits: A Smarter Way to Attract, Retain, and Engage" (photo by From Day One)Galvin said the decision to offer tuition reimbursement was an easy one. They want and need uniquely educated employees, and they offer a graduate program of their own, the Hazelden Betty Ford Graduate school, where students can earn master’s degrees in addiction and mental health counseling. “It’s one of our strongest recruitment pipelines,” she said. “Aside from career advancement and professional growth opportunities for our workforce, we saw this as a great opportunity to increase loyalty and job satisfaction. We know we’re creating a more motivated and engaged workforce. We feel that by investing in our workforce and their future, we are simultaneously investing in our own.”Running a Successful Student Loan Benefit ProgramWith her clients, Rubin discusses goals, budget, and workforce makeup. The latter is particularly important for employers that require their workers to have secondary or postsecondary degrees to qualify for the job. Those employees likely enter with considerable debt and would benefit from loan repayment benefits. Other employers may be heavily focused on upskilling the workforce they already have and would be wise to explore tuition reimbursement. Some will need both.Any student loan program requires a carefully prepared communication campaign that builds awareness and clearly outlines expectations. Rejecting reimbursement requests because the student disqualifies on a technicality or mistakenly promotes benefits to ineligible workers, will significantly damage the reputation of the program.At the Hazelden Betty Ford Foundation, Galvin folds the organization’s education assistance program into its benefits guide and stores it on the intranet. She also likes to promote it in sync with the school calendar when people are typically thinking about their education. Rubin said she likes to promote quick-start user guides and quarterly toolkits. But don’t wait for employees to arrive to advertise your program, they said, make it a part of your recruitment strategy. Tout it on your careers page and in your job postings.Galvin said the program has been remarkably successful for her organization. Those who have registered and activated their tuition reimbursement have stayed. “This has potentially retained 23 workforce members who may have otherwise left. Said another way, it’s potentially saved us over a million dollars in turnover costs.” Currently, there are 167 graduates from the Hazelden Betty Ford graduate school working at the foundation. “Those are employees who, more than likely, participated in tuition reimbursement and/or are now eligible for student loan repayment.” This, she says demonstrates the organization’s appreciation for those who both further their education and stick with the organization. Plus, it works.Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, Candidly, for sponsoring this webinar.Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza is a freelance journalist and From Day One contributing editor who writes about work, the job market, and women’s experiences in the workplace. Her work has appeared in the Economist, the BBC, The Washington Post, Quartz, Business Insider, Fast Company, and Digiday’s Worklife.

Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza | November 01, 2024

AI-Powered, Human-Centered Team Transformation at Scale

Work norms have shifted rapidly over the past four years. With hybrid work becoming the norm, organizations now face the challenge of engaging all team members while staying aligned with company goals.At From Day One’s Boston conference, AceUp’s founder and CEO, Will Foussier and chief technology officer, Rohit Begani, spoke in a thought leadership spotlight about “AI-Powered, Human-Centered Team Transformation At Scale.” Amid shifts in work locations, schedules, and efficiencies, some organizations lag in adopting AI—yet it can streamline operations and support flexible teams.Foussier cited a “connection crisis” affecting hybrid and dispersed teams. Nearly 80% of  employees work on a hybrid model, emphasizing the need to develop strategies for better  team engagement and collaboration, says Foussier. Among those 80%, only 23% expressed  feeling connected to the company. To address this, AceUp focuses on team coaching,  leveraging AI to drive business impact and connect teams to specific OKRs and KPIs.Begani, left, and Foussier, right, spoke during the thought leadership spotlightCompanies who utilize team coaching benefit from upskilling and reskilling opportunities and  can easily implement virtual team members into the happenings of the company. It is designed  to tailor the coaching to the needs and goals of the business. “The beauty of team coaching is that you can actually bring people together to address a business challenge,” said Foussier. AceUp created a way to effectively utilize AI to enhance current coaching sessions for  businesses rather than replace them altogether. They achieve this by focusing on AI-driven team-building methods that reshape how leaders and employees work together. “We have seen that it helps them clearly define a goal which is aligned with their business goal, and help them track the outcomes of team coaching,” Begani said.Using AceUp’s AI bot Ally, coaching sessions can now help companies detect and analyze  where improvement is needed. Ally joins the call as a normal coaching participant, captures  video, audio, and analyzes that data to discover breakthrough moments.  “With all of this data, we are able to provide hyper-personalized coaching–and this coaching  is for moments that matter,” Begani said. “These individuals are already going through coaching with a human coach, but because we have an understanding of their gaps, there's an  ability for a model to support them on specific needs.” Once the data from the team coaching sessions are collected, it is managed in a dashboard  that breaks down the information and reports any discrepancies. Then, the company can  assess and redirect to decide how to change them.  The future of leadership lies in teams. This idea inspired a team-coaching model that uses AI to collect session data, enabling personalized experiences, tailored goal setting, knowledge retention, and deeper insights into company dynamics. AceUp’s approach shifts from “me” to “we,” from leadership to team-ship, and from manager-as-coach to team-as-coach.Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, AceUp, for sponsoring this thought leadership spotlight. Mary Jones is a freelance writer out of Ohio. Her work is featured in several publications including The Dallas Express, NDash, and The Daily Advocate.

Mary Jones | November 01, 2024