Want to Retain Your Workers? Show You Genuinely Care About Their Mental Health

BY the Editors | November 20, 2024

When employers make a sincere effort to support the well-being of their workers, does that investment have a positive return for the company? Does it go beyond goodwill to improved corporate performance? Nivati, an employee mental-health platform, decided to find out.

In a study of 25,741 workers at 56 companies that used the Nivati platform during 2023-24, the company found a dramatic impact among employees who were fully engaged with the platform: a high level of employee retention. The overall turnover rate within this group of employees was only 1.7%, meaning they were eight times more likely to stay in their jobs than co-workers who were only casually engaged with the program.

Retention is a key number for employers because unwanted turnover can be so expensive. According to Gallup research, “replacing leaders and managers costs around 200% of their salary, replacing employees in technical roles costs 80% of their salary, and replacing frontline workers costs 40% of their salary, excluding unmeasured losses in morale and knowledge.”

Yet reducing employee turnover is not merely about cutting costs; it’s strategic investment in an organization’s future. By embracing programs that enhance engagement, satisfaction, and overall workplace culture, employers can cultivate a loyal and motivated workforce. The benefits—ranging from improved productivity to enhanced customer satisfaction—far outweigh the costs.

The American workforce’s state of mental health is often described as a crisis. How does that present itself on the job? “Employees often approach Nivati struggling with mental health challenges like stress, burnout, anxiety, relationship challenges, and work-life balance issues, which are major contributors to workplace dissatisfaction,” said Nivati CEO Amelia Wilcox, who founded the company in 2020. “When companies don’t provide mental health support, employees are more likely to leave due to feeling unsupported or unable to cope with their work environment.”

In the nearly five years since the start of the pandemic, many factors inside and outside the workplace have aggravated employee stress. “The shift to remote and hybrid work, combined with economic uncertainty and social isolation, has significantly affected employee wellness,” said Wilcox.

Amelia Wilcox, CEO and founder of Nivati (Company photo)

While many companies have stepped up their support for good mental health, there’s still a significant gap. “Many employees are still unaware of these benefits and underutilize them. This commonly stems from lack of communication and engagement strategies that remind employees and make employees feel like the resource is readily accessible and OK for them to use,” Wilcox said.

Cultural challenges are a factor too, especially when a company talks a good game about mental health but fails to make it a core value. “For instance, if a company is saying they value mental health and then covertly sends the message that taking time off is not OK, the employees internalize those covert messages over the overt messaging the employer is trying to send,” said Wilcox. “Effective onboarding, consistent conversations on mental health, periodic reminders, and visible support from leadership increase utilization, making employees more aware that their employer genuinely cares about their well-being.”

Karen Fikse, senior director of HR at Cummins, the engine manufacturer, said in a From Day One panel discussion that the idea of leaders practicing what they preach formed the basis of her company's “It’s Okay” campaign, which provides managers with resources to process whatever they’re going through–be it anxiety, stress, pressure or hardship.

In the five years since its Nivati’s inception, said Wilcox, “we’ve learned that the key to impactful mental health support is a holistic approach, including therapy, fitness, finance, and self-care tools, all made accessible within a flexible platform that meets employees where they are. We’ve also learned that some people aren’t comfortable with jumping right into therapy. So our platform was designed to allow people to start in an area that’s less ‘scary’ for them and build trust with the platform and team. They can take baby steps to grow into therapy.”

Before any therapy or other steps happen, the pathway needs to be a welcoming one. Nivati’s platform “provides an intuitive experience for employees to seek help: from signing in and selecting self-guided resources around mental health, nutrition, or finance—to scheduling and engaging with qualified professionals in each of those areas of well-being. The entire process is designed to be simple and confidential,” Wilcox said.

Nivati partners with a network of hundreds of licensed therapists, registered dietitians, life coaches, financial advisors, meditation practitioners, yoga instructors, personal trainers, and more. These providers work 1:1 with employees, they facilitate group training and education for Nivati’s customers, and they create the content for the self-guided resources on the company’s platform.

Even for workers who aren’t at risk of quitting their jobs, in many cases because they need the financial security, paying attention to their mental health can lead to thriving on the job rather than every day being a struggle. They can reframe their work experience and boost their resiliency. Nivati’s platform has a career development and coaching category to help workers grow in their roles as well. “Even if these employees aren’t leaving,” Wilcox said, “providing them with support can increase their satisfaction and productivity, ultimately benefiting both them and their employer.”

Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner Nivati, who sponsored this spotlight.

(Featured photo by SDI Productions/iStock by Getty Images)


RELATED STORIES

People-First, Performance-Focused: Linking HR Efforts to Bottom-Line Success

Despite HR’s new and powerful place in business, many leaders concerned with the bottom line struggle to understand the return on investment for HR’s activities, and many in HR struggle to communicate their value. But bridging human resources to the business isn’t an impossible task; in fact, it’s getting easier thanks to sophisticated HR tech and new access the department has to business leaders and their goals.Ken Matos, the director of marketing insights, and Keren Kozar, senior people and culture officer at HR tech platform HiBob says that the best way to make the connection is with what they call people-first HR.“People coming into the workforce are expecting a leader who genuinely cares about them and genuinely wants to see them be successful in the workplace,” said Kozar in a From Day One webinar on linking HR strategy to the bottom line. “[People-first HR] means that you’re considering your people. They’re not just a number.”“Every single department wants to contribute to a thriving company,” she said, but that may mean different things to different people. “For some, that 100% means the bottom line. For some people, that’s going to mean having an industry-disrupting product, but at the end of the day, happy, engaged employees who feel like they are contributing to an organization that cares about them are going to be the most successful, and that’s how a company is going to thrive.”The Latest and Greatest Business Expense: Artificial IntelligenceCompanies are cutting big checks for artificial intelligence–powered tools and all their promises, and entire organizations are receiving directives from the top: Start using artificial intelligence. But there’s little direction about how to use it, and the tech is still new to many users. Even without detail, departments will be asked to report how it’s improving their work.Ken Matos, Ph.D., the director of market insights at HiBob spoke during the webinar (company photo)Treat AI like a hypothesis to be tested, said Matos. “The first thing is to understand your theory of change for AI.” Identify the problems you believe an AI tool will solve, and “once you have that, you can move on to measurement.” Measure whether people are using it, then track how they’re using it and what they’re producing. “If you know what that chain is supposed to look like, you can pick key places where there are doubts or possibility for failure and focus on measuring those bits. And if the end result is what you’re looking for, then odds are that the whole thing worked.”Linking HR to the Bottom LineIf you want to get business leaders to listen, find out what motivates them. If they want to increase revenue, then it’s your job to identify how people affect revenue with not just what they do, but how they do it.“You can articulate to a leader that you want to get sales revenue up, and here are a bunch of enablers, or obstacles,” Matos said. “My job is to make sure those enablers are maximized. Here’s how and how these obstacles are removed.” With that, those business leaders will start seeing you as an ally, not an admin.And if you’re going to vouch for the efficacy of HR and its work, then you have to speak the language of the business. Kozar once worked for a company where the leader was “100% a numbers guy” who cared only about the balance sheet. “He used to say, ‘HR, you’re so touchy feely.’ And my response would be, ‘people are a measurable metric. They matter. That is a data point. People’s feelings are actually a data point. You need to consider it, just like you would consider absolutely any other analytic that factors into your business decision.’”This can’t end with employee sentiment surveys, though. “We often talk about how to align with leaders and how to communicate with them, but it’s just as important to make sure that HR leaders are speaking to every level of the business,” she said. “So talk to individual contributors, your entry-level folks. The best feedback that I get is from the individual contributors and entry-level people that I’m just sitting with at lunch. That’s how I’m going to synthesize anecdotal feedback and deliver that back to leaders in a way that they’re not going to get through an engagement survey.”Those who chafe against the notion of people-first HR do so because they “don’t realize how feelings change the effectiveness of their business,” said Matos. Think of it this way: How many times have you avoided emails or a project because there’s a person on your team who slows down the work, or is simply a pain to work with?Matos often speaks to business leaders who wonder why it’s their responsibility to motivate the workforce. Maybe you can’t motivate them, he said, but you can certainly demotivate them. “You can strip away their natural desire to do their job, from micromanaging to disrespect to not being communicative. All of these are things under your control.”Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, HiBob, for sponsoring this webinar.Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza is an independent journalist and From Day One contributing editor who writes about business and the world of work. Her work has appeared in the Economist, the BBC, The Washington Post, Inc., and Business Insider, among others. She is the recipient of a Virginia Press Association award for business and financial journalism. 

Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza | January 31, 2025

Benefits Recap & Forecast: Navigating Alternative Health Plan Choices in 2025

On a summer day in 2024, Matt Cook, chief commercial officer of Firefly Health, suddenly felt some pain in his stomach. He reached out to his Firefly care team and scheduled a 15 minute appointment with a nurse practitioner who ordered him to get a CT scan. The results showed Cook had appendicitis and the next day he was scheduled for a surgery. All of this happened within 72 hours of care.Firefly Health is a virtual-first healthcare company that offers an alternative health plan that aims to make it easier for people to get the care they need. During a From Day One webinar, journalist Jenny Sucov spoke with Cook and Erik Sossa, independent advisor and consultant to Firefly and former Vice President of Global Benefits and Wellness at PepsiCo about health plan trends and challenges employers face with the changing landscape for benefits.The Shortfalls of Typical Healthcare BenefitsWhile Sossa was working with PepsiCo., he felt that employers were leaving employees to manage their benefits on their own. “They had to deal with changes in annual enrollment, finding an in network provider, prior authorization and an explanation of benefits,” he said.Despite the value of healthcare benefits, corporations are taking away from the positive employee experience while they themselves are struggling with the cost of providing care for their workers. “Employees oftentimes are facing the brunt of some of those tough decisions in the form of maybe a more restricted plan,” said Cook. “Affordability is such an issue for both the employee and employers themselves.”Coming from the corporate side, Sossa acknowledges that companies struggle with cost sharing and sometimes burden employees with having to educate themselves on healthcare plans while they may not have the time to learn the ins and outs of health insurance.“For an employee who doesn’t navigate healthcare for a living, they serve our companies for a living, that’s a tremendous burden on them to try to navigate through this,” said Sossa. “That’s part of the dynamic and one of the things I’m very excited about with companies like Firefly that are trying to really change that paradigm.”Matt Cook, the chief commercial officer of Firefly Health, spoke during the webinar (company photo)Cook said that one group that launched Firefly’s health plan alongside traditional plans told them that Firefly was “the first plan they ever offered where frontline workers and executives alike chose the same plan.” The concept of healthcare affordability is not just with money, but also time. For busy workers, healthcare is only useful when it can be accessible according to the member’s schedule.What is Alternative Healthcare?Alternative health care is an alternative to “historical medical plans that have been delivered in this country across a consolidated set of health plans that are out there today,” said Cook.Firefly is trying to “rethink” the medical plan experience by taking off the burden that has been placed on employees. Sossa views it as the “next evolution” of healthcare. “It’s an alternative to a broken system but hopefully that alternative becomes more and more of the status quo as we rethink the way healthcare needs to be delivered in this country,” Cook said.The new generation of healthcare that Sossa envisions is one that is affordable, accountable, productive and healthy. Firefly is using industry wide data sets on wellness, prescription drugs and labs to understand the gaps that need to be filled in healthcare.Firefly’s model allows patients to quickly schedule a 15 minute visit and continue the engagement in between visits. The company found that there were more longitudinal engagements with its members that were dealing with chronic conditions, some of which they were seeing two dozen to 100 times a year. In a primary care system, they might be visiting their doctor once a year, said Cook.The company offers both virtual and in person care through local partnerships. Firefly uses a care model that ensures members are consistently met with the same team throughout their journey.Pitching New Programs to StakeholdersChanges in new programs, like healthcare, can be exciting but it has to be approved by company stakeholders in order to be implemented. Sossa said when something new is being pitched, you have to have a “clear understanding of your audience and speak their language.”When talking to the CFO, understand the marketing, investments and advertising aspects. When discussing with human resources, touch on the represented population, labor landscape and contracts. Sossa says stakeholders will be more receptive to ideas that are half-baked, ones that require some brainstorming.“Bring them the idea at a 30% mark, where you have the ability to sonar ping with them, get their influence and get their reaction. But if you have a chance to sonar ping your ideas as you go through, that makes them part of developing the solution, and they are much more receptive to that,” Sossa added.He encourages corporate leaders to “resist the gravitational forces of short term thinking” and consider how something that will be sustainable and will solve issues takes time. Sossa advises his clients to think of themselves as moving into the first year of a three year strategy. “Aim a little higher in your steering,” he said.The Future of HealthcareAlternative healthcare is at an inflection point, but it is still a slow progressing industry as they introduce the concept to the corporate world, says Sossa. Cook added that the inflection comes at a time where provider shortages are only getting worse.“Ultimately, the average person is going to be looking for that accessible, high quality care and I think that moment is coming. We need to bring great quality care to our people, not leave it to them to go and figure out where to find it,” said Cook.More competitors are entering the alternative health care industry and the adoption of it is going to increase in 2025, predicts Sossa. Especially with growing frustrations on the traditional healthcare models and lack of progression to meet members’ needs.Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, Firefly Health, for sponsoring this webinar. Jennifer Yoshikoshi is a local news and education reporter based in the San Francisco Bay Area.

Jennifer Yoshikoshi | January 27, 2025

Is It Time to Break Up With Your HR Tech?

Looking into new technology always takes time to research and adopt, but organizations should not put it off simply because it’s a lot of work. “There is constant evolution of technology,” said JJ Carpenter, senior account executive at Rippling, a platform designed to streamline HR, IT, and financial processes. “There are different systems out there today that maybe didn’t fit your bill a year ago.”Carpenter spoke about HR tech at From Day One’s November virtual, offering suggestions on how to approach new tech that could potentially make a big impact on how a company functions.Could it be time to shop around for new tech? HR technology should be evaluated regularly—typically every two to three years, though some companies do so annually, Carpenter says—to determine if it still meets organizational needs. Key triggers for evaluation include disconnected or inefficient systems, workarounds or manual data entry, duplicate processes, and the use of multiple unintegrated systems.Rather than sticking with outdated methods, organizations should stay informed about new solutions that may better fit their needs. Technology evolves, and what wasn’t a good fit before might be now. Regularly exploring options ensures HR systems remain effective and efficient. He spoke on what to look for in HR tech. Excerpts:Manual vs. AutomationOne of the most critical considerations is automation, as many HR tasks are still manual, creating inefficiencies and an increased administrative burden. Carpenter suggests evaluating HR tech with these questions: Are processes still paper-based? Do approvals require physical sign-offs? Is duplicate data entry a recurring issue? Can workflows be automated to reduce human intervention?A robust HR tech solution should provide automation that improves efficiency, reduces errors, and maintains an audit trail for tracking and reporting. “You don’t want employees to fall between the cracks,” Carpenter added. “Otherwise, they’ll get online and start looking at other companies. You want to try to retain those employees, that talent.”Organizations should evaluate whether their current system requires excessive manual input and whether automation can streamline transitions, promotions, and other workforce changes. Company BackgroundUnderstanding the history, structure, and direction of an HR tech provider is essential. In addition to evaluating present-day features, it’s important to consider the long-term partnership potential. Key questions to ask include: Is the system natively built, or is it a collection of acquired tools? Do different modules integrate seamlessly, or are they patched together? How often does the provider update and improve its technology? What does the provider’s roadmap look like for the future? JJ Carpenter a senior account executive at Rippling led the thought leadership spotlight (company photo)A well-integrated system helps prevent hidden inefficiencies that could impact long-term usability. Forward-thinking organizations should also assess the provider’s approach to AI development, security, and legal frameworks, including: Are AI-driven features being developed, and how will they impact HR teams? What data security measures are in place for AI functionalities? How does the provider handle contracts, including annual increases and master service agreements (MSAs)?Assessing these factors upfront ensures alignment between the HR tech provider and an organization’s strategic goals, Carpenter says.User-Friendly InterfaceEase of use is a major factor in the success of any HR tech platform. If employees and HR teams struggle to navigate the system, adoption rates will suffer. “Once we have a tool, will people actually use it? The worst thing you can do is invest in a tool you think solves a problem, only to find it creates a whole new one.”A user-friendly system reduces frustration, accelerates onboarding, and ensures employees and administrators can leverage its full capabilities without excessive training. Carpenter suggested not just asking if a function exists—ask the provider to demonstrate it.Test the TechBefore committing to an HR tech solution, it’s important to test it firsthand. Carpenter urged companies to request a sandbox environment to explore features, a demo showcasing real-world scenarios, and opportunities for HR teams to interact with the platform before implementation.“It’s got to be something that’s going to take away your burden, or at least help mitigate it,” he said.Reporting CapabilitiesData-driven decision-making is a cornerstone of effective HR management, and a strong HR tech solution should provide robust reporting capabilities, including customizable reports on workforce trends, compliance tracking for various regulations, easy export options for integration with analytics tools like Tableau or Power BI, and visibility into key HR metrics across multiple locations and entities.Organizations should ensure their HR tech allows them to track performance, generate insights, and make strategic decisions efficiently. “You want to focus on reducing your admin time and increasing your strategy, which boosts productivity,” Carpenter said.Customer Service & Response TimeReliable customer support is crucial when issues arise, as employee hours are valuable, and HR tech should build efficiency—not create more work while users sit on hold. When evaluating HR tech providers, consider Service Level Agreements (SLAs) for response times, Customer Satisfaction (CSAT) scores and user reviews, the availability of self-service options, and dedicated support models, such as pod-based support teams.A provider with strong customer support ensures that technical issues and inquiries are addressed promptly, minimizing disruptions to HR operations.Return on Investment & Management Buy-in“Sometimes other parties need to be involved more than you initially expect. Typically, you might start with an HR evaluation and realize IT needs to be part of the discussion, especially for security concerns,” Carpenter said.Look for tools that provide documentation, ISO and SOC certifications, and transparency around their security measures. These aspects are critical when presenting to leadership or a board.A strong business case for new HR tech should include time savings, as manual tasks consume valuable hours that translate into salary costs; administrative costs, since excessive administrative work reduces strategic focus and profitability; and long-term efficiency, as reducing manual work improves overall productivity and operational effectiveness.To build a persuasive case, outline the problem, the cost of inaction, and the benefits of the new solution. Decision-makers will weigh factors such as implementation time, cost, ROI, and associated risks.Effective evaluation involves a phased approach, system consolidation, and change management to ensure a smooth transition. Testing before implementation is crucial to preventing unforeseen challenges. In the end, making a well-informed decision based on both current and future needs will set an organization up for long-term success. “There is a cost to change,” Carpenter told attendees, “but there’s also a reward if you make the right decision.”Investing in the right solution can drive efficiency, improve compliance, and enhance the employee experience. By focusing on automation, company background, usability, testing, reporting, support, and ROI, organizations can make a smarter, more strategic decision that scales with growth.Editor's note: From Day One thanks our partner, Rippling, for sponsoring this thought leadership spotlight. Carrie Snider is a Phoenix-based journalist and marketing copywriter.

Carrie Snider | January 24, 2025