Failing Well: How Your Company Can Provide Room for Failures That Foster Success

BY Katie Chambers | January 17, 2024

Tennis legend Billie Jean King once said, “For me, losing a tennis match isn’t failure, it’s research.” Amy C. Edmondson, the Novartis Professor of leadership and management at Harvard Business School, shares this quote in her latest book, Right Kind of Wrong: The Science of Failing Well, which won the “Best Business Book of the Year Award” from the Financial Times. The book illustrates how we and our organizations can embrace our human fallibility, learn exactly when failure is our friend, and prevent most of it when it is not. It’s the key to pursuing smart risks and preventing avoidable harm.

At From Day One’s January monthly conference, which focused on making a fresh commitment to a culture of well-being in the workplace, Edmondson shared specific strategies for how organizations can benefit from failure, a skill that is becoming more and more important in today’s business environment. “In turbulent times, failure is even more likely. And in more turbulent times, innovation and problem solving are more important than ever, and they bring the risk of failure.” While it’s easy enough to recognize this intellectually, Edmondson said, “being able to put into practice the truth of those behaviors is something else altogether.”

Good vs. Bad Failure

“A good failure is the undesired result of a thoughtful experiment,” Edmondson said. That experiment, to be considered a “good failure,” should meet four criteria:

  1. It’s in genuinely new territory–it really has never been tried before. 
  2. It should be as small in scale as possible. 
  3. It should be in pursuit of a specific goal, “not just playing around with resources,” Edmondson said.
  4. And thanks to some thoughtful research, you should already have a sense that the experiment may work.

A “bad failure,” Edmondson posits, happens when you violate any one of those four criteria. For example, she shared, “You roll out an uncertain product in your entire market, rather than pilot testing it somewhere smaller. So even something that’s potentially good violates the size criterion, and then isn’t so good.”

Simple failures can be forgetting to check a basic safety feature, but there are complex failures as well: “The multi-causal, ‘perfect storm’ kinds of failures that arise when a variety of things come together in just the wrong way, any one of which, on its own, wouldn’t have caused the failure.” The recent debacle with the door plugs on Boeing 737s, she says, is a perfect example.

Pivoting to a Productive Failure

Moderator Adi Ignatius, editor-in-chief at the Harvard Business Review, posited a scenario that many modern business leaders are all too familiar with. “You have a strategy that’s based on a big product rollout that takes years to develop. And then near launch, the CEO decides this is not the right approach, and this massive project with all these people attached to it is suddenly stopped. How do you handle the disappointment? How do you make this a productive failure?” he asked.

Amy Edmondson spoke about her book Right Kind of Wrong: The Science of Failing Well in conversation with Adi Ignatius, editor-in-chief at the Harvard Business Review (photo by From Day One)

Edmondson views this instance as an intelligent failure, suggesting that reframing it as a learning opportunity and acknowledging the effort invested can transform it into a productive experience. “You do it explicitly out in the open. You frame it as a really worthy effort that wasn’t able to achieve what you had hoped it would achieve,” she said.

Some companies even celebrate failures. For example, in the pharmaceutical space, the vast majority of projects fail. It’s just the nature of the scientific experimental process. Eli Lilly, Edmondson says, has parties at the end of failed clinical trials to still celebrate its achievements. This achieves three goals: it satisfies the need for recognition, potentially prevents the same failure from recurring, and it makes the team more likely to end a failing experiment in a timely and cost effective way, knowing that there will still be some sort of positive outcome.

At Takeda they don’t celebrate failure, that’s a bridge too far for their traditional Japanese culture, Edmondson says. But they do celebrate the pivot. “The difference is that the failure is the end, it's looking back, whereas the pivot is looking forward. Same ritual, different language,” she said. “For their culture, they are celebrating the fact that they worked hard.”

Learning From and Admitting to Failure

“Our temptation is very strong to gloss over it. No one wants to dwell on a failure,” Edmondson said. But the formal post-mortem process is important. Rather than placing blame on any one individual or entity, companies should approach it simply, briefly, and effectively: What happened? This is essential especially for multi-dimensional projects with potentially conflicting viewpoints and experiences.

“Rather than a lengthy research project, this should be a quick compiling of the narrative so that we understand it better and resist the temptation to just say, ‘we'll try harder next time’ or ‘it wasn’t our fault, it was bad luck,’” Edmondson said. Organizations should walk away with key learnings as to what went wrong and how to improve on that process in the future.

It can sometimes be challenging for certain individuals to admit to failure. But that’s exactly why it helps to have a ritualized process for acknowledging and addressing it. “If this is what we do around here, they’ll want to play the same sport,” Edmondson said. Organizations should build trust with their employees that there is a safe environment for acknowledging fault. “We are fallible human beings, and we have to be fine with that,” she said. “We are better team members when we are fine with that.”

Building Psychological Safety

How you handle failure as an organization should be a part of an overall strategy for building an environment of psychological safety. “The most important thing is to early and often call attention to the attributes and aspirations of the work that involves unfamiliar territory, stretches, or challenges,” Edmondson said. “We’re sending the intellectual message that ‘we need you, we need your voice and we need you to speak up if we’re to do well on these ambitious goals.’”

Companies should also encourage a culture that welcomes inquiry. “The more facile we get at asking good questions, the kinds that give the other person a clear signal that we really want to hear from them, the more we’re creating psychological safety for speaking up,” Edmondson said. The safer employees feel communicating with leadership teams, the more likely they are to address failures early and often–turning them into opportunities for learning and growth.

Katie Chambers is a freelance writer and award-winning communications executive with a lifelong commitment to supporting artists and advocating for inclusion. Her work has been seen in HuffPost, Honeysuckle Magazine, and several printed essay collections, among others, and she has appeared on Cheddar News, iWomanTV, and CBS New York.


RELATED STORIES

How “America’s Diner” Creates a Culture for Workers to Grow and Thrive

Fasika Melaku, SVP of HR and chief learning officer at Denny’s, is a big believer in career mobility. After all, she attended Emerson College to become a speech pathologist and ended up on an entirely different path. She credits the restaurant industry’s innate ability to provide a clear pathway for promotion as part of the reason she is where she is today.Melaku started as a restaurant hostess when she was in high school, working her way up the ranks. Now, she is committed to raising up employees at all levels. “I help engage our teams at Denny's from the hostess to the CEO, and discuss how we can create brilliance for our teams and for our guests when they walk in,” she said in a fireside chat at From Day One’s July virtual conference.Denny’s offers an ambitious career-development program for all of its 70,000 employees at more than 1,600 locations. Melaku provided an inside look at how the company’s ‘gain’ program provides support for workers in four key areas, including life skills and career pathways.Moderator Lydia Dishman, senior editor, growth and engagement at Fast Company notes that Denny’s provides “a support ecosystem that enables you to grow and learn.” In order to lay that foundation, Melaku says HR leaders need to start at the source. “I think one of the number one people in your ecosystem to support is you,” Melaku said, noting the importance of simply wanting to get up and go to work every day. “How we nurture that is creating a purpose that people can engage with, that you can find your place in. [For Denny’s], it’s our love for feeding people, body, mind and soul.”Part of that is ensuring all employees have a shared language around corporate values. “At Denny's, we have this culture that we wrap around called the Denny's Way. Using consistent language [ensures that] everybody gets it. It’s not hidden,” Melaku said. “It is a beautiful thing that’s given from the CEO, all the way down to the server and the cooks. That's a huge part of how we create mobility and how we start life at Denny’s.”Most Denny’s restaurants are franchise-owned, with 210 owners spread across the country. It can be a challenge to teach everyone in all of these locations, which is why that consistency in language is key.“The culture was already there,” Melaku said, but language needed to be shared. So, Denny’s brought everyone to the table, with all departments and franchises meeting in person over the course of three days. She says people left feeling more like a part of something bigger and could envision their place in the Denny’s ecosystem.Providing a Platform for MobilityIn a modern job environment that prioritizes skills-based hiring, “the restaurant industry is at an inflection point, teaching people this set of skills that they can take anywhere, or stay here with.” We often don't think about mobility in the service industry as staying within the service industry, but Denny’s wants to prepare its employees for long-term growth and career longevity.Lydia Dishman of Fast Company interviewed Fasika Melaku of Denny's in the virtual fireside chat (photo by From Day One)“You learn stuff when you’re working in the service industry day in and day out. How do we flip the script in the world to make sure they know what you learn here, leading a restaurant that is a $3 million business, is just as worthy as what you learn in a classroom?” Melaku said.The gain program harnesses the energy and passion of its employees who run a 24-hour business. It gives employees who need it the opportunity to get their GED while working for Denny’s, and ensures that the management training provided onsite could be seen by colleges as equivalent to higher education courses. Today, Melaku says, their program is equivalent to 30 college credits with three universities – and they’re going after more.The gain program also provides life skills training, including financial planning courses to help employees better understand how to manage the money they earn while working at Denny’s. This is more training than many college graduates may receive, says Dishman.Often, Melaku says, Denny’s is where employees learn the skills that will help them improve the situation for themselves and their families, whether that’s through the Star Management training program or simply learning basic skills on the job.Melaku shares the story of Michael Best, who started working at Denny’s at age 16 and now leads new restaurant openings at the organization. “He said Denny’s managers helped teach him about accountability,” Melaku said. He became the first person in his family to purchase their own home. “That’s the beauty of a supportive ecosystem.” Denny’s prides itself on being a bedrock for people and often providing them with their first job.Paying to train an employee only to have them walk out the door, then having to pay to train their replacement, is a particular challenge in the restaurant industry, where competition is fierce. “It is crucial that we think about our people. If you don’t figure out how to make people feel like they belong, if they don’t feel like it’s OK to take some time off, if they don’t learn – that’s tough.” Melaku has been in consistent conversation with the 200 owners to show them the data backing up how the gain program impacts retention.In terms of getting through to the employees themselves, Denny’s is transparent with its employees, showing how the pathway from server to general manager can lead to personal financial success. “In every onboarding you have, we tell them about the growth,” Melaku said. “It pays to help them see the value you bring to them as an individual, [how you] help them with their families, and teach them life skills. When you open that door to create success, your business will succeed.”Katie Chambers is a freelance writer and award-winning communications executive with a lifelong commitment to supporting artists and advocating for inclusion. Her work has been seen in HuffPost and several printed essay collections, among others, and she has appeared on Cheddar News, iWomanTV, and CBS New York.

Katie Chambers | July 23, 2024

How Digital Tools Give Talent Leaders More Time to Invest in Their Candidates

Innovative tools like AI not only help you get things done, but also free up time for you to reinvest in yourself. “It's important to be your authentic self. And to be your best self, you also have to take care of yourself. So if we can leverage AI and other technology tools to free up time, everyone has a choice to seek how to best reinvest that,” said Paul Phillips, global head of talent acquisition and onboarding at Avanade. That reinvestment can be taking a walk or spending more time with your kids, says Phillips, who spoke in a fireside chat at From Day One’s June virtual conference.Avanade is a joint partnership of Accenture and Microsoft focused on IT consulting of the Microsoft stack. With those credentials, “innovation is critical to our everyday business,” Phillips said. That means that job applicants must “feel and sense that they are working and operating with a leading innovator from the tech perspective.”AI is used throughout the Avanade acquisition process, beginning with writing the job ad itself. Using AI apps to craft the job description shaves 13 minutes off a task that had previously taken 15 minutes, he says. Then they use AI during the screening and evaluation process. The company does offer candidates globally the choice to opt out of the AI talent acquisition process, which about 30% do. But for the rest of the talent pool, the AI matching tool gives his team more precise matching of candidates to jobs and saves at least five days of traditional screening time.“When you multiply that by 5,000 hires, and multiply that by revenue per day, we’re talking multiples of millions of dollars that this is helping us generate on our top line growth,” Phillips said. Every applicant also has a human touch from his team, but the AI grading tool has proven to be very accurate. “It’s anywhere from two to five times more likely that anyone who is graded A or B is likely to get an offer,” Phillips said.Journalist Jeanhee Kim interviewed Paul Phillips of Avanade during the fireside chat (photo by From Day One)Technology is not the only way Avanade innovates, however. Phillips spoke about a change to the three pillars of their talent strategy. To the core talent acquisition goals of  “attract, develop and retain,” his team has added “create.”“What we meant by that was our ability to actually create a new talent workforce within the Avanade ecosystem that could ultimately enable us to overcome some shortages of skills,” Phillips said. To start, Avanade began casting a wider net that looked for markers of potential to learn new skills and be retrained. “That means that we look for talent that maybe has not interacted with the Microsoft technology set, or those that may have been a performance management consultant so they have a lot of skills,” he said. And they train them, through a program called Avanade Academy. This hiring strategy has been a huge success from a diversity perspective, says Phillips.This all started in Brazil, where they hired 200 women to train in the academy a few years ago. “Not only did we see a huge spike in our diversity hiring percentage, we actually started to see a shift in the culture and the behavior of the business,” Phillips said. “Globally, in female hiring, we are striving towards parity. We’ve doubled in the last five years, from 20%, to 40%,” he said.Casting a wider net in hiring has other implications for the agility of a company, too. There’s an estimate that 85% of the jobs needed in the next five years are currently unknown. So for companies to stay abreast, hiring teams have to look for individuals who can “learn, unlearn, relearn,” and have “agility, courage, and resilience. These are different skills that we may have in the past overlooked or not seen as important.”Phillips had some comforting parting advice for those who may be daunted by the challenge of using technology in hiring and for hiring for skills that may not have even been invented yet. “Don’t be fully focused on getting it all right on day one,” he said. “We live in a very iterative world today. People are happy with continuous progress. Despite all the technology, we’re still human at heart.”Jeanhee Kim is an independent journalist who has worked for CoinDesk, Crain’s New York Business, Money magazine and Forbes Asia.

Jeanhee Kim | July 16, 2024

Using Innovative Technology and AI to Revolutionize Hiring for Top Talent

Like many other companies, MGM Resorts has been undergoing a talent acquisition transformation over the past few years in the wake of the pandemic and the Great Resignation. “We’re enacting a strategic way for recruiters to evolve into more of an advisor role,” said Justin Fronberg, executive director of talent acquisition for MGM Resorts.Fronberg spoke during an executive panel discussion about “Using Innovative Technology and AI to Revolutionize Hiring for Top Talent,” during From Day One’s June virtual conference. “What’s been critical for us is to relieve them of the transactional aspects of the position,” he said.Fronberg told journalist and session moderator Lydia Dishman that using an AI chatbot creates efficiencies for recruiters and job candidates alike. The chatbot allows candidates to determine if an open position is something they are actually interested in without talking to a recruiter, he says.Some people have reservations about using AI in recruitment, but Jane Curran, global head of talent acquisition at JLL, reminds her team that “you can’t put the genie back in the bottle.” “The tech is here, and we are ready for automation. So why don’t we dig in and find out what works for us, leave the human parts of the job to us, and automate the boring stuff?” she said.How AI Can Broaden the Talent PoolIf used correctly, implementing AI in recruitment can also reduce bias, says Ken Oliver, vice president of corporate social responsibility at Checkr. “We can focus on things like skill-based learning and the different skill sets that the candidate may have rather than look at things like gender, race, or age, which sometimes come up in the recruitment process,” said Oliver.AI can also help expand the talent pool by looking beyond more mainstream job boards such as Indeed, says Oliver. “To get the most diverse and inclusive candidates, oftentimes you have to look in some of the most unusual places," he said, noting that this could include social media.However, AI is “only as good as what you input it with,” he said. For example, if a candidate has a legal record, there’s typically not much understanding “about what that means or what it doesn’t mean, especially when it comes to a specific role.”But with AI, “we can provide much more context around the candidate and the specific charge, the date of charge, and whether it’s relevant to the job,” Oliver said. This scope can lead companies to consider candidates that they might have traditionally overlooked, says Oliver.Using AI in the Interview ProcessAnother way organizations can ensure their workforce is diverse is to standardize the job interview process using AI. “This allows candidates of diverse backgrounds to be evaluated fairly against objective criteria that should be set at the beginning of the process, rather than try to make that up towards the end,” said Seán Delea, team manager of talent acquisition, EMEA at Greenhouse.For example, a recruiter and a hiring manager will align on a number of key attributes needed for someone to be successful in a particular role and then design an interview process to assess candidates for those attributes objectively, says Delea.“Then you can do things like use AI to help you generate some of those interview questions. This step alone is helping to reduce human bias when you’re building out the best interview process,” he said.The panelists spoke on the topic "Using Innovative Technology and AI to Revolutionize Hiring for Top Talent" (photo by From Day One)Christopher Rotolo, VP of global talent at Mitek, says technology has helped standardize the interview process and also write job descriptions. “It literally will pull out the skills and create the interview questions, the guides, the scoring sheets and everything, from soup to nuts,” he said.The AI technology Mitek uses comes with a package of possible interview questions that the hiring manager and the talent acquisition partner can tweak so “candidates aren’t hearing the same question over and over through the interview process,” Rotolo said.Some organizations use tools to automate the interview scoring process, even “inferring personality through speech patterns and tone,” Rotolo said. “And I think that will mature. We’ll all be talking about that probably three to five years from now.”Keeping the Human ElementBut even with all of these innovative AI tools, the human touch is still needed, says Curran. For example, when it’s time to promote someone, “You need to know the talent,” she said.“Who’s the top talent I should be helping make the next move? The connection, the career conversation, the prep, that’s the recruiter’s job,” said Curran.“[Candidates] want to be treated like a person rather than a number. So, we abide by the stance that AI should assist but not replace humans in the hiring process,” said Delea.Mary Pieper is a freelance writer based in Mason City, Iowa. 

Mary Pieper | July 10, 2024